As they often do — and, frankly, as they’re intended to do — the latest batch of rankings from the College Football Playoff selection committee ignited debates across the country about where various teams were placed in the top 25.
Much of the controversy this past week
was not centered around the top of the rankings, but the bottom, which featured four SEC teams with four losses apiece ranked between the No. 21 and No. 25 spots.The confusion over their inclusion extended to maybe the most prominent face and voice in the sport.
During an appearance on Thursday, Nov. 19 on “The Pat McAfee Show,” longtime ESPN college football analyst Kirk Herbstreit told
the show’s eponymous host and his “College GameDay” colleague that No. 21 South Carolina, No. 22 Oklahoma, No. 24 Florida and No. 25 Mississippi remaining in the top 25 didn’t quite add up to him.
“What happened at the bottom doesn’t make a lot of sense to me, with South Carolina losing at Arkansas,” Herbstreit said. “Oklahoma’s been trash all year. Florida’s not a very good team. They’re very erratic and inconsistent.”
"What happened at the bottom of the CFP Top 25 didn't make a lot of sense to me..
— Pat McAfee (@PatMcAfeeShow) November 19, 2026
I was very surprised by that" ~ @KirkHerbstreit #PMSLive pic.twitter.com/Sjq95YcO59
Though it came without star quarterback LaNorris Sellers, who was out with an ankle injury, South Carolina was drubbed on the road, 34-6, by an Arkansas team that was 3-6 and had lost four of its past five games entering the matchup.
Though Oklahoma has enjoyed a nice bounce since making a change at offensive coordinator, the Sooners are still just 4-3 in SEC play, have an ugly loss to a reeling Michigan team and have the No. 106 scoring offense in the FBS.
And after a hot start under first-year head coach Jon Sumrall, Florida is 2-4 since the start of October.
“I don’t like that bottom line,” Herbstreit said. “I’m not a big fan of a lot of those teams down there from the SEC. I heard (ESPN reporter) Heather (Dinich) and others who have talked about this new thing that they’re talking about, strength of conference or something like that. It’s a new variable, a new metric that they’re looking at. But I was very surprised on that part.”
Herbstreit wasn’t totally aghast at what he saw in the bottom quarter of the rankings.
He praised the committee for moving Arizona up four spots to No. 19 after the Wildcats narrowly lost at home to No. 2 Utah, 40-39, last Saturday in a game that had three lead changes in the final 12 minutes. Arizona fell to 7-3, with all three losses coming to teams in the top 12 of the CFP rankings, two of which were decided by one score.
“People think we push the SEC, but I push teams,” Herbstreit said. “If that’s the No. 2 team in the country, and I think they are, Arizona had them on the ropes until the final gun. … Tip of the cap to the committee for doing that, as they sit at 7-3 in the Big 12. How many people would have thought a Big 12 team at 7-3 would be in the top 20 off of a loss late in the year? That’s something they did right.”
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Kirk Herbstreit rips latest CFP rankings: 'Bottom doesn’t make a lot of sense to me'













