Spoiler alert: This story contains major spoilers from the season finale of "The Traitors: New Blood," which aired Nov. 19 on NBC.
Like his bank account, Shane Beatty's spirits are up after "The Traitors: New Blood" finale Thursday, Nov. 19.
The 32-year-old ironworker from Staten Island made reality TV history as the winner of the first-ever civilian player season and the first recruited traitor to ever win the U.S. franchise.
Yet his victory was not only bittersweet but emotionally gutting for him and viewers. The New Yorker fully broke down after revealing to faithfuls Abbey Benjamin and Wyatt Gillespie that he had betrayed them in the end after they fully trusted him.
Realizing the $246,000 prize pot had escaped her reach, Abbey soon followed
suit, sobbing in agony while a distressed Wyatt paced around speechless. Beatty explained that he started out as a faithful and was given an ultimatum to become a traitor before proceeding to cry again.
"I felt so bad. I didn't feel like a winner in the moment," Beatty tells USA TODAY. "I just felt so guilty because I built the trust with these people. I built an alliance. I built a friendship."
Beatty said it was crushing to see Benjamin and Gillespie's devastation knowing he had caused it, causing him to break down again.
"But then they came to comfort me, which speaks a lot about their character. These people are good sports. They're not sore losers and they understand my situation," he says.
Abbey and Wyatt explain why they comforted traitor Shane
While grappling with deep betrayal, the two losing faithfuls decided to comfort the winning traitor.
Gillespie, a 26-year-old designer from Pennsylvania, said he looked at Beatty and realized his tears came from a different place.
"He's crying with guilt. And to me, that's a horrible feeling to have. Like, yes, I just lost. I can put that aside in the moment because I see an individual who's like genuinely suffering," Gillespie says. "That's my guy from the beginning and I would have done the same exact thing. I mean, I tell him, I walk up to him, I shake his hand up, good game, would have done the same exact thing. Like I can't loom over something that I can't control."
Benjamin said it took her a bit longer to compose herself than what the edited episode shows. While she couldn't find the words to say in that moment, she knew she could comfort Beatty with a hug.
"I'm thinking about Shane. I'm thinking about his mom. I'm thinking about his fiancée and I cannot throw red to get him out just because of one suspicion of heavy feet. I just couldn't do that," she says. "I couldn't actually like bring anything out of my mouth, but he was hurting in a different way than we were."
With non-celebrity players, the stakes are much higher, the players echoed. Benjamin said when you vote for a player you're also voting against their family and their future, an energy that haunts the room in a way she says viewers can't comprehend.
Overall, the pair are proud of the game they played as faithfuls and would easily go back and play again, though Gillespie clarifies he's ready to be a traitor the second time around.
What will Shane do with his $246K check?
While Beatty plans to set himself up for success with his $246,000, he also plans to pay for an extravagant wedding with his fiancée.
"She does not want a cheap wedding," he says. "And then I'm gonna have my mom with some, some whatever situations I can help her with, whatever small financial debts I can get her out of. And then the rest of the money, I have no materialistic items I want to buy. I'm saving it for myself, so I'm not living, check to check."
And yes, the guest list will include several members of the cast including his fellow traitor Katie Frites, whom he betrayed in the final five vote, and the sweaty yet passionate Victor Vollbrechthausen. If the star-crossed pair show up as each other's dates, then Beatty will ask his soon-to-be wife to just throw a bouquet right at them.
"Their relationship is very, very interesting because what will happen with them, you know? Who knows?" he says.
Vollbrechthausen, 26, and Frites, 23, agree their chances at showing up to the wedding as a couple are a "maybe" but they'll for sure both be there.
"I'm not sure. We're we're figuring it out. I mean, we went through a lot of trauma in that castle," Vollbrechthausen says. "We can we can slowly but surely, you know, build some trust back and see where that takes us."
Frites replied "Funny enough, like, sometimes he'll say something and I'm like, I don't really believe you. I just I don't know what it is about you. Like, I just can't shake the feeling that you're like a traitor."
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: 'Traitors: New Blood' winner speaks out after $246K betrayal of faithfuls













