NEW YORK ‒ Every so often, there’s a musical that reminds you just how heavenly a night of theater can be.
Sure, that may sound like an awfully grandiose way to describe something as well-trodden as “The
Fantasticks,” which has been kicking around every high school and community playhouse for decades. But at a moment when so many Broadway shows are crutched by insipid star casting and overblown vocal gymnastics, Christopher Gattelli’s sublime and heart-tugging revival feels like an antidote to an industry that’s increasingly allergic to simple, earnest storytelling.
“The Fantasticks” initially opened off-Broadway in 1960 and went on to set a record for the world’s longest-running musical of all time, running for 42 years and more than 17,000 performances. Barbra Streisand, Gladys Knight and Tony Bennett all put their indelible spins on its lush score by Tom Jones and Harvey Schmidt, spawning standards including the starry-eyed “Soon It’s Gonna Rain” and gorgeously wistful “Try to Remember.”

Although it has always been a love story between a young man and woman, Gattelli’s glittering new production shifts the action to a winsome gay couple: the brash and bookish Matt (Maxim Chlumecky) and the sweet yet self-absorbed Lewis (Nathan Levy), who pine for each other across an imposing garden wall that separates their two houses.
The boys are led to believe that their romance is forbidden, and through song, they vividly rewrite their Shakespearean tragedy as a fairy tale bursting with passion and heroics. But in reality, their mothers Bessie Mae (Ruthie Ann Miles) and Mildred (Leslie Rodriguez Kritzer) are actually close friends who have tricked them into falling in love, knowing that children always desire most what they can’t have.
Like the recent “Gypsy” and “Cats: The Jellicle Ball” before it, this “Fantasticks” manages to be modern without ever pandering, gently uncovering rich new textures of the story that feel like they have always been there. Any young queer person can understand how it feels to be trapped and misunderstood, yearning for a world that you know is so much brighter and grander than what’s in front of you.

But Gattelli also recognizes the jealousy, lust and confusion that can seep into a monogamous relationship, as Matt and Lewis become disillusioned and find their eyes wandering to the brawny, baritone bandit known as El Gallo (Zane Phillips, in a sensitive yet swoony revamp of the Jerry Orbach character).
Jones’ lightly updated book also changes the boys' fathers to mothers, bringing a deeper sense of warmth and affection to Mildred and Bessie Mae, who only wish to protect their queer children and see them thrive. Miles and Kritzer, too, are an infectiously delightful duo: In the showstopping “Never Say No,” you can’t help but beam from ear to ear as they milk every waggish turn of phrase for all its worth. (“Why did the kids put beans in their ears? / No one can hear with beans in their ears / After a while the reason appears / They did it ‘cause we said no.”)
There’s not a single weak link in the cast: Chlumecky radiates star power in a performance that is playful, sexy and tremendously tender. His voice fits like a dream with the appealing Levy, who reduced many in the audience to buckets of tears with the older-but-wiser “They Were You.” Broadway veterans David Patrick Kelly and Kevin Del Aguila are also a laugh riot as a droll pair of pratfall-prone actors hired to fake an abduction.

Perhaps most refreshing of all is Gattelli’s loving direction and sprightly choreography. There’s an unmistakable affection for the material that permeates every element of this production, from Linda Cho’s whimsical costumes to Jen Schriever’s picturesque lighting. Gattelli leaves ample room for reinvention, but he also knows when to cede the spotlight to Jones and Schmidt’s intimately beautiful and clever score.
There are some folks who may take issue with the more meandering second act, as Matt and Lewis are faced with the stark realities of happily ever after. Others may find it difficult to get up swept in a musical that is so pleasantly straightforward and unabashedly silly at times.
As for us, we found “The Fantasticks” utterly enchanting from start to finish. Good luck to every other Broadway show opening this season – it’ll be one tough act to follow (follow, follow, follow).
“The Fantasticks” is now playing at the Hayes Theater (240 W. 44th Street) through Feb. 7, 2027.
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: 'The Fantasticks' is the most heart-tugging show on Broadway – Review








