
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth has made more news than most of his predecessors, to say the least.
Most recently, he made headlines for being admonished by – then formally lauding – a soldier who scolded him alongside a group of his senior advisers for laughing at the Tomb of the Unknown Soldier after a Veterans Day ceremony.
Like most of President Donald Trump's Cabinet members, he contains multitudes and divides public opinion – even his title isn't settled law in modern parlance.
So before Hegseth narrowly survived an impeachment vote on Nov. 10 (with a possible assist from DC traffic?), we asked you, our readers, to weigh in on the controversial Pentagon chief, the value of impeachments potentially to come under impending Democratic leadership
and the state of the U.S. military under Hegseth.
Read a collection of your responses below. To participate in future Opinion Forums, check in at usatoday.com/forum or drop us a note at forum@usatoday.com.
Hegseth impeachment drama is just bad politics
Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth should absolutely not be impeached or criticized in any manner. His actions thus far only serve to protect the interests of the United States and, in some cases, the entire free world. I think this whole situation is simply bad politics; I think it’s laughable that they wanna impeach Hegseth.
— Bruce Hunt, California
We can't weaponize impeachment, tempting as it is
Hegseth was fundamentally unqualified on day one. His tenure has proved to be a dangerous failure of constitutional governance, military readiness and the rule of law.Leading the Pentagon demands strategic competence and strict adherence to civilian-military norms. His record represents reckless, unchecked executive overreach. The secretary of Defense must be held accountable to the Constitution, not personal whim or partisan spectacle. Hegseth has demonstrated contempt for Congress, our service members, and basic checks and balances.
I have zero admiration for anyone in this administration. Across the board, they strike me as self-serving opportunists, grifters and media hounds who hitched their wagons to President Donald Trump for personal fame, financial benefit and political clout.That being said, other Cabinet members should not be impeached right now.The Constitution is clear on the threshold for impeachment: treason, bribery or other high crimes and misdemeanors. Disliking an official’s character, despising their regulatory policies, or thinking they are unqualified hacks does not make them impeachable.
If we start weaponizing impeachment just because we don't like the people in power, we reduce a grave constitutional safeguard to petty, reflexive playground politics – the exact same behavior we criticize when an executive uses the pardon power like party favors for political cronies.
— Matthew Nelson, Missouri
Hegseth's warrior mindset is a welcome change

As a U.S. Army and Vietnam-era veteran, I agree with everything the secretary of War is doing! Eliminating drug boats is a good deed for the world and gives the pilots some worthwhile target practice. I wholeheartedly agree with shedding paper pushers with outdated combat experience from the top ranks. I spent most of 1969 in the Pentagon and saw what these "combat vets" do there. Deposed Venezuelan dictator Nicolás Maduro played the game and finally met a worthwhile adversary. I have no regrets or sympathies for that drug lord.
I agree with Hegseth's warrior ethos, and the military needs to go back to that. Basic training should not be summer camp. He only lived up to his (new) title.
Too many members of Congress are there for the pension. Most have little (remembered) history of our country, and the new ones weren't taught history by qualified teachers. Anybody who graduated high school after 1975 should be made to take the citizenship test before they can vote or run for office.
This impeachment nonsense is just a fit of pique by small-minded, moderately educated, jealous people who are lucky their voters are less informed than they are.
— George Leibowitz, Florida
Voters made it clear leaders like this must go
Hegseth is a disgrace. There's a reason so many high-ranking military officials (and former officials) have risked their own careers to speak out against him publicly. He is unilaterally involving our military in unauthorized war efforts, ordering military personnel to commit what appear to be war crimes and destroying morale within the ranks. His ousting of career military members who are transgender, for example, is needless, unpopular and likely illegal. These people will win in their inevitable court cases, and we'll all pay.
He is unable to separate his role as a former Fox News pundit from his very serious duties and obligations to our Constitution and the American people. Every event is a spectacle, and far from the somber approach someone dragging the country into conflict after conflict should be taking. He's focused on culture wars, "owning the libs" and injecting our military men with testosterone while simultaneously risking the lives of thousands of enlisted in conflicts around the globe.
Voters sent a very strong message, including Republican voters. If congressional Republicans aren't responsive to what happened in the midterm elections, it's all the better for Democrats in 2028.
— Sarah Bricker Hunt, Ohio
Hegseth took DEI hires out of our military
Hegseth has done a great job. He had to refocus our military on being competent warfighters, with no room for trans people or weak and incompetent diversity hires allowed in by former President Joe Biden's administration.
As far as military actions are concerned, he has reestablished the United States as a country that will not tolerate communism and narco-terrorism in our region. This will make America safer in the future by sending a strong message to all of our adversaries.
Nobody in President Trump's Cabinet should be impeached, now or ever. This is the best presidential administration I have seen in my lifetime.
History will show why the Trump administration has been one of the very best in U.S. history. Just look at how much they have accomplished in just two years. When Trump took office, he had to fix all the damage that former President Barack Obama and the Biden administration had done over 12 years.
— Jake Vink, California
This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Hegseth is dangerous, but we can't weaponize impeachment | Your Turn













