Nashville's oldest hardware store, Cumberland Hardware Co., plans to close its doors for good at the end of 2026. Owners John and Sheila Varallo announced the closure on Sept. 1.
"This decision was not made lightly," the Varallos said. "Over the years, we have been honored to serve this amazing community, celebrate events like the Tomato Art Fest, and witness neighbors come together to support one another during strong storms and difficult times. We have watched this neighborhood grow and change, and we have been grateful to be part of it."
The Varallo family took over the hardware store in East Nashville's Five Points neighborhood in 1984 and has continuously operated it since then, alongside several resident cats who helped welcome in customers.
Before that, the hardware store served Nashvillians for decades, tracing back more than 122 years to the early 1900s.
After several free parking options in Five Points were turned into paid lots at the start of 2026, parking for customers became an issue for businesses in the area. The Varallos didn't specify the reasoning behind their decision to close, but they have previously been outspoken about declining customer numbers because of parking challenges.
"We are deeply thankful for your loyalty, trust, and support. You have allowed us to be more than just a hardware store — you have allowed us to be part of your lives, your homes, and your stories," the Varallos said. "Thank you for supporting our family-owned business for the past 42 years. It has truly been our privilege to serve you, and we will always cherish the memories, friendships, and relationships we have built along the way."
Hadley Hitson covers business news for The Tennessean. She can be reached at hhitson@gannett.com. To support her work,subscribe to The Tennessean.
This article originally appeared on Nashville Tennessean: Nashville family-owned business will close after over 120 years of history
