For the Keeper of the Classics
Every family has one person whose holiday spirit is powered by pure nostalgia. Their pick is often a black-and-white film that reminds them of their own childhood. Honoring this choice connects generations and keeps timeless stories alive. Let them queue
up 'It's a Wonderful Life' (1946) or the original 'Miracle on 34th Street' (1947). These films are classics for a reason, offering heartfelt messages about community and kindness that resonate just as strongly today. Even if younger viewers initially resist a movie that isn't in vibrant color, they often find themselves drawn into the story, creating a shared experience that's richer than just watching the latest blockbuster.
For the Modern Comedy Lover
There's always someone who believes the holidays should be more about laughter than anything else. Their choice will likely be a more modern film filled with quotable lines and hilarious situations. Think 'Elf' (2003), where Will Ferrell’s earnest Buddy the Elf clashes with cynical New York City, or 'National Lampoon's Christmas Vacation' (1989), a masterclass in holiday chaos. These movies provide a necessary dose of levity during a season that can sometimes feel stressful. Embracing their pick ensures the movie marathon includes moments of outright joy and big laughs, reminding everyone not to take the holiday pressures too seriously.
For the Youngest in the Room
Giving the kids a turn at the remote is non-negotiable for family harmony. Their pick will almost certainly be animated, and it's a great opportunity to see the holidays through their eyes. Films like 'The Polar Express' (2004) capture the pure magic and wonder of Christmas Eve. Other fantastic choices include the beautifully hand-drawn 'Klaus' (2019) or the perpetually charming 'A Charlie Brown Christmas' (1965). These movies are often designed for co-viewing, meaning they have enough heart and cleverness to entertain adults, too. It’s a pick that makes the youngest members of the family feel seen and valued.
For the Unconventional Watcher
Is it really Christmas without a debate over whether 'Die Hard' (1988) is a holiday movie? Every family seems to have a member who delights in picking a film that stretches the definition of 'Christmas movie'. It could be an action flick set during the holidays, a dark fantasy like 'The Nightmare Before Christmas' (1993), or a creature feature like 'Gremlins' (1984). Leaning into this choice adds an element of surprise and can introduce the family to an edgy new favorite. It acknowledges that holiday spirit isn't always wrapped in a perfectly tidy bow.
For the Hopeless Romantic
Some people see the holidays as the perfect backdrop for a love story. Their go-to picks are often ensemble comedies or charming romances that mix festive cheer with heartfelt emotion. 'Love Actually' (2003) and 'The Holiday' (2006) are quintessential examples, weaving together multiple storylines of connection and romance against a Christmassy setting. These films bring warmth and sentimentality to the queue, satisfying the desire for a feel-good story where, despite the odds, love wins out in the end. It's a reminder that connection is at the heart of the season.
Making the Tradition Stick
To turn this from a one-time experiment into a beloved tradition, set a few ground rules. Make the selection process part of the fun—draw names from a hat or go in age order, alternating each year. Create a cozy atmosphere with blankets, special snacks, and hot cocoa to make movie night an event. The most important rule is that once a movie is picked, it’s locked in. This teaches a gentle lesson in compromise and respecting others' tastes. The goal isn't for everyone to love every second of every movie; it's to love the experience of watching them together.













