Set the Scene: Welcome to the Arconia
Ambiance is everything. Dim the lights and evoke the classic, pre-war elegance of the show's iconic New York apartment building. Start with the soundtrack: the show's jaunty, mysterious theme song is a must, followed by a playlist of instrumental jazz
or classic Broadway tunes that Oliver Putnam would adore. For the dress code, encourage guests to choose their character. Will they be cozy in Mabel's tie-dye hoodie, dapper in one of Charles's sharp coats, or theatrical in an Oliver-esque scarf? Don't forget the details—maybe even print out a few mock building notices from Bunny Folger to leave around the room for guests to discover.
The Spread: Dips, Dips, and More Dips
It wouldn’t be an Only Murders party without an obsessive amount of dip. Take a page directly from Oliver's book, who famously considers dips a complete meal. You can't go wrong with a robust spread of Greek options like hummus, tzatziki, and baba ghanoush, a nod to the Dimas family's culinary influence in the early seasons. For a more interactive element, you could feature a “mystery dip” and have guests try to guess the flavor, inspired by a real-life Tostitos promotion. And while less practical for a party, you could offer a knowing wink to Charles-Haden Savage with a mini-omelet station. For dessert, cookies are a must, referencing Ben Glenroy's obsession with Schmackary's in a previous season.
Libations for Amateur Sleuths
Every detective needs a good drink. Create a menu of themed cocktails and mocktails that channel the main trio. For Charles, a classic Old Fashioned or a simple, sophisticated red wine feels right. Oliver demands something with more flair—perhaps a colorful, dramatic gin cocktail with a theatrical garnish. For Mabel, consider a modern and trendy Mezcal Negroni or a vibrant, non-alcoholic punch you could cheekily name a "Bloody Mabel." For a simpler, all-purpose option, you can't go wrong with coffee in New York-style blue and white paper cups to capture that bustling city energy.
The Viewing Slate: A Cozy Mystery Marathon
While the main event is the latest episode of Only Murders in the Building, you can extend the night by pairing it with another mystery. For a classic feel, the 1985 cult favorite Clue is a perfect match, sharing a similar blend of ensemble comedy and whodunit antics. If you want something more modern but equally star-studded and witty, Rian Johnson's Knives Out offers another intricate family mystery for a detective to solve. For a TV option, a series like Poker Face or The Afterparty shares that "case-of-the-week" feel with a humorous twist, keeping the energy light and engaging.
The Post-Show Debrief: It's Podcast Time
Once the credits roll, the investigation begins. Encourage your guests to channel their inner podcasters and discuss their theories. Who is the killer? What clues did they spot? You could even record your conversation on a smartphone for the full meta-experience. To keep the fun going, switch from watching mysteries to solving one. Break out a murder mystery board game or a collaborative puzzle. The point isn't just to watch the show, but to do what Charles, Oliver, and Mabel do best: come together, share some laughs, and get to the bottom of it all before the next episode airs.
