An Exploitation Throwback with a Twist
To understand 'Thanksgiving,' you have to go back to 2007's 'Grindhouse,' a passion project from directors Quentin Tarantino and Robert Rodriguez. The film was a double feature, presenting Rodriguez's 'Planet Terror' and Tarantino's 'Death Proof' as a throwback
to the gritty, low-budget exploitation films of the 1970s. To complete the experience, they invited filmmaker friends—including Roth, Edgar Wright, and Rob Zombie—to create fake trailers for non-existent B-movies that would play between the main features. Roth, along with his childhood friend Jeff Rendell, had long joked about the lack of a Thanksgiving-themed slasher movie, despite growing up in Massachusetts where the holiday is a massive cultural event. The 'Grindhouse' project was the perfect opportunity to finally create their twisted vision, a gory send-up of holiday slashers like 'Halloween' and 'My Bloody Valentine.'
The Joke That Wouldn't Die
Shot in just two days at the end of filming 'Hostel: Part II,' the 'Thanksgiving' trailer was a masterclass in condensed chaos, featuring a Pilgrim-masked killer, a trampolining victim meeting a bloody end, and a human turkey being roasted. It was an immediate cult favorite. Fans loved the over-the-top concept so much they began asking a simple question: when is the real movie coming out? For years, Roth and Rendell had no answer. The problem was that the trailer was all punchline and no plot. It was a collection of memorable kills, not a story. Trying to write a script by connecting the dots between the trailer's gags proved to be a creative dead end. The project languished, but fan demand never disappeared, with people constantly reposting the trailer and asking Roth for updates.
Finding the Meat of the Story
The breakthrough came when Roth and Rendell stopped trying to literally adapt the trailer. Instead, they came up with a new premise: what if the trailer was for a 'lost' film from 1980, and their new movie was a modern reboot of it? This freed them to create a new story while cherry-picking the best elements from the original concept. The second key inspiration was disturbingly modern: viral videos of Black Friday shopping riots. This gave them the perfect inciting incident for a slasher film—a tragedy that connects a group of people who, a year later, find themselves targeted by a killer seeking revenge. The killer was named John Carver, a nod to the first governor of the Plymouth Colony, a historical detail that gave the villain a local, thematic anchor. This new plot focused on a Black Friday riot in Plymouth, Massachusetts, that ends in tragedy, sparking a vengeful killing spree the following Thanksgiving.
Serving a Polished, Modern Slasher
The final film, released in November 2023, is a different beast from the grainy, 1980s-style trailer that inspired it. Roth opted for a clean, contemporary look, treating it as a modern slasher in the vein of 'Scream' rather than a retro pastiche. While some iconic moments from the trailer made the final cut—like the parade mascot's demise—the film stands on its own with new characters, a whodunnit mystery, and kills designed to top the original gags. The story centers on a group of high schoolers and town residents, including a sheriff played by Patrick Dempsey, who are hunted by the mysterious John Carver. The result is a film that honors its bizarre origins while functioning as a full-fledged, modern horror movie, finally filling the Thanksgiving-sized hole in the holiday slasher calendar that Roth and Rendell first noticed as kids.













