The Setting: A Dilapidated American Dream
Before we even meet the full family, we meet the apartment. It's a pre-war, two-level unit in Manhattan's Chinatown, the new home of millennial daughter Brigid and her boyfriend, Richard. But this isn't a bright, aspirational space; it's a character in itself,
and it’s deeply unwell. The walls are stained, the pipes groan, lights flicker, and strange thuds echo from the upstairs neighbors. For the visiting Blake family from Scranton, Pennsylvania, the apartment is a physical manifestation of their collective anxieties. The setting immediately establishes that this Thanksgiving won't be a Norman Rockwell painting. It's a claustrophobic, unsettling space that perfectly frames a family quietly—and sometimes loudly—falling apart at the seams.
The Silent Generation: A Ghost at the Feast
The matriarch of the family is Momo, Erik's mother, who is wheelchair-bound and deep in the throes of dementia. For most of the film, she is a peripheral presence, murmuring incomprehensibly. Her condition makes her a living ghost at the feast, a constant, uncomfortable reminder of mortality, decay, and the inevitable passage of time. For her, Thanksgiving is a haze, a tradition she can no longer participate in. Yet, she represents the history and traditions the family is struggling to maintain. Her meaning to the holiday is found in a lucid email she wrote years prior, read aloud by her daughter-in-law Deirdre, offering loving advice. It's a heartbreaking glimpse of the person she was, making her silent presence at the table a symbol of a past that is both cherished and irrevocably lost.
The Boomers: The Burden of Fading Stability
For parents Erik and Deirdre, Thanksgiving is an exercise in maintaining control in a world that feels increasingly unstable. Erik, the patriarch played with world-weary anxiety by Richard Jenkins, is haunted by financial precarity and a secret that threatens to unravel the family's carefully constructed image. Deirdre clings to her Catholic faith and traditions, gifting her daughters a statue of the Virgin Mary and pleading with them to value the struggles that she believes build character. Their version of Thanksgiving is tied to the American Dream they bought into—one of steady jobs, religious faith, and providing a better life for their children. But that dream is crumbling. Their holiday is less a celebration of gratitude and more a fraught performance of normalcy, shadowed by the fear that they have failed to secure their legacy and their children's futures.
The Millennials: Anxiety, Authenticity, and New Traditions
For daughters Aimee and Brigid, the holiday is a complex negotiation between old expectations and new realities. They have rejected their parents' religious faith and small-town life for secular, urban futures that are far from secure. Aimee, a lawyer, is dealing with a recent breakup, a precarious career, and a chronic illness. Brigid, an aspiring musician, is saddled with student debt and creative anxieties. For them, Thanksgiving is less about honoring the past and more about seeking connection and validation in the turbulent present. They want their parents' approval but resent their judgment. They mock their mother's forwarded emails while desperately needing her love. Their Thanksgiving is an attempt to forge new traditions—like smashing a peppermint pig for good luck—while navigating the minefield of modern anxieties their parents don't fully understand.













