The Internal Collapse of 'Krisha'
Trey Edward Shults’ debut feature, 'Krisha,' is less a movie you watch and more a panic attack you experience. The film’s claustrophobia is entirely psychological, trapping the audience inside the fractured mind of its titular character. Krisha (Krisha
Fairchild), a recovering addict, returns to her estranged family for Thanksgiving after a decade-long absence, determined to prove she’s changed. From the moment she arrives, the film’s formal elements conspire to create a sense of overwhelming internal chaos. The camera is a frantic, roving entity, swirling around the bustling house and getting uncomfortably close to faces, mirroring Krisha’s own disorientation and rising anxiety. The sound design is a cacophony of overlapping conversations, barking dogs, and a percussive, dread-inducing score that feels like the protagonist's racing heartbeat. Shults even manipulates the aspect ratio; as Krisha’s sobriety and composure begin to crack, the frame literally closes in on her, shifting from a wider 1.85:1 to a more constricting 2.35:1, visually squeezing the world around her. This isn't the fear of being trapped in a room; it’s the horror of being trapped in a downward spiral, with your own mind as the prison.
The Architectural Rot of 'The Humans'
If 'Krisha' is an internal implosion, Stephen Karam’s adaptation of his own Tony-winning play, 'The Humans,' is an external, environmental decay that seeps through the walls. Here, the claustrophobia is architectural and shared. The Blake family gathers for Thanksgiving in the cavernous, eerily empty pre-war apartment of daughter Brigid (Beanie Feldstein) and her boyfriend Richard (Steven Yeun). The apartment itself is a character—a decaying, two-level space in Chinatown with peeling paint, flickering lights, and unsettling noises from neighbors and groaning pipes. Karam leans into the story's stage origins, often framing the action with a static, voyeuristic distance. Characters are frequently obscured by doorways or walls, making the audience feel like an unwelcome ghost eavesdropping on private griefs. As the sun sets, the apartment grows progressively darker, with shadows swallowing the characters as their secrets and anxieties—financial ruin, chronic illness, infidelity, existential dread—come to light. The fear in 'The Humans' is the slow, creeping realization that the structure meant to provide shelter is just as broken and unstable as the family within it.
An Explosion vs. a Slow Decay
Both films brilliantly weaponize the single-location setting, but their approach to generating unease is fundamentally different. 'Krisha' is an active, kinetic force. Its tension comes from the protagonist herself, a human time bomb whose desperate attempts to hold it together only accelerate her spectacular detonation. The camera’s subjectivity forces us to align with her, making her eventual relapse feel both inevitable and personally devastating. The claustrophobia is one of proximity to a volatile, unpredictable element. 'The Humans,' in contrast, is passive and atmospheric. The Blake family members are slowly suffocating under the weight of their quiet, collective despair. Their dread isn’t a sudden explosion but a mold that has been growing for years, now made visible by the stark, decaying setting. The film’s horror is quieter, rooted in the terror of generational anxiety and the feeling of being trapped not by a person, but by circumstances. One film is about the monster you bring with you into the house; the other is about the monsters already living in the walls.













