Game Night (2018)
If the Halloween Heists were your favorite part of 'B99,' this movie is your next obsession. 'Game Night' follows a group of hyper-competitive friends whose murder mystery party gets hijacked by a real kidnapping. The result is a high-stakes action-comedy
where ordinary people are forced into extraordinary circumstances, much like the precinct facing a new foe. Jesse Plemons' turn as a creepy, lonely neighbor is a Holt-level deadpan performance that steals every scene he’s in. It flew a bit under the radar but is a masterclass in escalating absurdity and ensemble chemistry.
The Other Guys (2010)
This is the most direct parallel to 'Brooklyn Nine-Nine' on the list. It centers on two desk-jockey detectives (Will Ferrell and Mark Wahlberg) who live in the shadow of the precinct's superstar cops. Sound familiar? It's essentially the story of Hitchcock and Scully deciding to become Jake and Amy. The film lovingly sends up cop movie tropes while delivering surprisingly solid action and a plot that’s smarter than it has any right to be. It perfectly captures the 'B99' mix of workplace incompetence and surprising moments of genius.
Kiss Kiss Bang Bang (2005)
For fans of fast-talking, pop-culture-savvy dialogue, this is the Holy Grail. Robert Downey Jr. plays a petty thief who accidentally lands an audition for a detective movie and gets paired with a private eye (a never-better Val Kilmer) for research. It’s a sharp, witty neo-noir that constantly winks at the audience, much like Jake Peralta breaking the fourth wall with his 'movie-isms'. The central partnership is a chaotic mix of bickering and bonding that feels like a more cynical Jake and Charles. It was a box office dud that's now a beloved cult classic.
Spy (2015)
Imagine if Gina Linetti was a secret agent. Melissa McCarthy stars as a desk-bound CIA analyst who goes into the field for the first time. She's consistently underestimated but proves to be incredibly competent, mirroring the 'B99' theme that heroes come in all forms. The film also features a hilariously unhinged performance from Jason Statham, playing an over-the-top secret agent that feels like a British Pimento. It’s a brilliant send-up of spy movies that, like 'B99,' has a deeply lovable and capable underdog at its core.
The Nice Guys (2016)
Take the buddy-cop energy of Jake and Holt, set it in the 1970s, and you get 'The Nice Guys.' Ryan Gosling's bumbling private eye and Russell Crowe's gruff enforcer team up to solve a case involving a missing girl and the porn industry. Their dynamic is pure comedic gold, with Gosling's high-pitched screaming in the face of danger providing a perfect counterpoint to Crowe's world-weary professionalism. Despite rave reviews for its sharp script and chemistry, it criminally underperformed at the box office.
Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves (2023)
This film has no business being this good, and its core strength is pure 'Brooklyn Nine-Nine' found-family energy. A charming bard leads a group of mismatched adventurers (a stoic barbarian, an insecure sorcerer, a by-the-book paladin) on a heist to right a past wrong. The characters gently mock each other's flaws but have unwavering loyalty, creating the exact same warm, fuzzy feeling as watching the 99th precinct come together. It's funny, heartfelt, and action-packed, a true gem that deserved a bigger audience.
Attack the Block (2011)
If the 99th precinct was a group of teens from a South London housing estate fighting off an alien invasion, you'd get 'Attack the Block.' The film blends sci-fi horror with sharp, funny dialogue and a surprisingly poignant story about community and disenfranchisement. It’s a cult favorite that launched John Boyega’s career and features an ensemble of young actors who feel like a real crew, protecting their turf with fireworks and bravado. It has the scrappy, underdog energy that defined the precinct's best moments.
Galaxy Quest (1999)
A perfect found-family story disguised as a sci-fi parody. The washed-up cast of a 'Star Trek'-like show gets abducted by aliens who believe their series was a historical document. They are forced to become the heroes they only ever pretended to be. The cast's journey from cynical, bickering has-beens to a genuine, functioning crew is pure 'B99' heart. It's a loving tribute to fandom and the idea that even flawed people can rise to the occasion, which is the precinct's entire mission statement.
The Man from U.N.C.L.E. (2015)
For those who appreciate the slick, stylish side of things, this Guy Ritchie film delivers. An American spy and a KGB agent are forced to work together during the Cold War, and their clashing personalities create an endless stream of witty banter and perfectly-timed physical comedy. It’s like a season-long arc where Holt is forced to partner with his arch-nemesis, the Vulture, but with more fashion. The film is impossibly cool and funny, but it got lost in a crowded summer release schedule and deserves a second look.
Midnight Run (1988)
An absolute classic of the 'unlikely partners' genre. Robert De Niro is a bounty hunter trying to bring a mild-mannered accountant, played by Charles Grodin, across the country. Their cross-country journey is a masterclass in comedic chemistry, with Grodin’s deadpan annoyance slowly breaking down De Niro’s tough-guy exterior. It’s the original 'Jake and Holt on a road trip' story, full of heart, legitimate stakes, and two characters who grow to respect and care for each other despite their differences. It's less 'underrated' and more 'criminally underseen' by younger audiences.













