Two Twists on One Premise
On the surface, 'Planes, Trains and Automobiles' (1987) and 'Dutch' (1991) share a deceptively simple plot: a chaotic, multi-day journey to make it home for Thanksgiving dinner. Both were written by John Hughes, a filmmaker who practically owned the 80s
suburban psyche. 'Planes, Trains' follows uptight ad executive Neal Page (Steve Martin) on his disastrous trip from New York to Chicago, made infinitely more complicated by his forced companionship with the oafish but good-hearted shower curtain ring salesman Del Griffith (John Candy). Four years later, 'Dutch' flipped the script slightly. Working-class hero Dutch Dooley (Ed O'Neill) volunteers to drive his wealthy girlfriend's snobbish son, Doyle (Ethan Embry), from his Georgia boarding school to Chicago for the holiday. Both films are road movies fueled by disaster, but their central conflicts and comedic tones reveal two very different takes on the same idea.
The Irresistible Force vs. The Immovable Object
The magic of a road comedy lives or dies on its central pairing. 'Planes, Trains and Automobiles' gives us two adults who are, on some level, peers. Neal's mounting frustration is aimed at an equal, a fellow traveler whose relentless optimism and accidental sabotage drive him to the brink of insanity. Del is annoying, to be sure, but he's a lonely man desperate for connection, and John Candy's performance is so full of warmth that you can't help but feel for him even as he exasperates Neal. 'Dutch' presents a different dynamic: adult versus child. Doyle isn't just a travel companion; he's a surrogate son figure Dutch must win over. Doyle is initially presented not as a lovable nuisance, but as a genuinely hateful little snob, a product of his wealthy, cynical father. The conflict isn't just about surviving the journey; it's a battle of wills between a blue-collar guy trying to teach a lesson and a privileged kid who thinks he knows everything.
Comedy of Frustration vs. Comedy of Aggression
While both films find humor in travel nightmares—rerouted flights, burnt-out cars, sketchy motels—their comedic flavors are distinct. 'Planes, Trains' excels at situational comedy and character-driven humor. The famous rental car counter scene, where Neal unleashes a torrent of rage, is funny because it's a relatable fantasy for anyone who has ever been stuck in travel hell. The humor comes from watching a man who prides himself on control completely lose it. 'Dutch' leans into a more aggressive, sometimes mean-spirited comedy, especially early on. The film's opening salvo involves Doyle attacking Dutch with a golf club, and Dutch responding by physically forcing him into the car. It’s a darker, more confrontational humor that softens as the film progresses but starts from a place of genuine antagonism rather than circumstantial annoyance.
The Thawing of the Heart
For all their slapstick and rage, both movies are ultimately about empathy. 'Planes, Trains' is a masterclass in the slow burn of understanding. Neal starts by seeing Del as an obstacle, a bumbling idiot who is ruining his life. The turning point is the famous motel room scene where Neal's cruel outburst is met with Del's wounded confession: 'I like me. My wife likes me'. It’s the moment Neal begins to see the man behind the annoyance. 'Dutch' achieves a similar thaw, but it's more of a mentorship. Dutch's goal isn't just to get Doyle home, but to break through his entitled shell. By forcing Doyle to experience life outside his bubble—staying in a homeless shelter, hitching a ride with prostitutes—he teaches him about humility and respect. In both films, the destination becomes less important than the journey of seeing the other person as a human being.
Defining the Thanksgiving Spirit
More than any other holiday, Thanksgiving is about the complicated reality of family and belonging. 'Planes, Trains and Automobiles' crystallizes this with its poignant final reveal: Del Griffith has no home to go to. His wife has passed, and his cheerful tales of home life are a defense against his profound loneliness. Neal's decision to bring Del home for Thanksgiving with his family is the ultimate act of found family, a perfect embodiment of the holiday spirit. 'Dutch' offers a more traditional but equally earned resolution. Dutch succeeds in delivering Doyle to his mother, not as a piece of cargo, but as a changed, more considerate person. The final scene shows the creation of a new, blended family, with Dutch having earned his place at the table. Together, the two films created a genre by understanding that the journey home for Thanksgiving is never just about the turkey. It’s about the frustrating, funny, and ultimately necessary process of connecting with others.













