The Political Powder Keg
In ‘The Oath,’ the dread is external, loud, and brutally immediate. The 2018 film, written and directed by Ike Barinholtz, imagines a near-future America where citizens are asked to sign a loyalty oath to the President by Black Friday. The Thanksgiving
dinner table becomes the primary battlefield for this ideological war. The tension isn't just about what's happening outside; it's about how that national crisis infiltrates the most personal of spaces. Barinholtz plays Chris, a cable-news obsessed liberal whose righteous indignation boils over at his family members who either signed the oath or don't see the big deal. The dread builds through explosive arguments, as family members weaponize political talking points against each other. The film uses the familiar tropes of a dysfunctional family holiday—the overbearing host, the provocative relative, the peacemaking spouse (played by Tiffany Haddish)—and cranks the political temperature to an unbearable level. The horror comes from watching a recognizable family dynamic fracture under the weight of national division, culminating in a home invasion that transforms the political into the dangerously physical.
The Rot From Within
If ‘The Oath’ is an explosion, ‘The Humans’ is an implosion. Adapted from his own Tony-winning play, Stephen Karam’s 2021 film finds its horror not in a national crisis, but in the quiet, creeping decay of a single family. The Blake family gathers for Thanksgiving in the rundown, barely furnished Manhattan duplex of daughter Brigid and her boyfriend. The setting itself is a major source of dread; the apartment is plagued by strange noises, flickering lights, and water stains that look like rot, mirroring the family's internal state. The anxiety here is economic and existential. Patriarch Erik (Richard Jenkins) is haunted by a secret and the feeling of financial failure. Daughter Aimee is dealing with a chronic illness and a breakup, while Brigid resents her parents for not funding her artistic dreams. The dread in ‘The Humans’ is atmospheric and psychological. It’s the slow-drip of resentments, the unspoken disappointments, and the crushing weight of unrealized potential. There are no political arguments, only the profound sadness of a family realizing they are not, and perhaps never were, okay.
Two Roads to Ruin
Both films use Thanksgiving as a pressure cooker, but they heat it with different fuels. ‘The Oath’ is a satire of our political polarization, demonstrating how easily national schisms can sever familial bonds. Its dread is active and confrontational; you can hear it in the shouting matches and see it in the final, violent confrontation. It suggests our biggest threat is the ideological enemy we invite to dinner. ‘The Humans,’ on the other hand, presents a more insidious form of dread. The horror is passive and pervasive, like a mold growing in the walls. The family’s problems—aging, illness, financial precarity, disillusionment—are the mundane terrors of modern American life. There is no single villain or external force to blame; the enemy is the slow, inevitable erosion of hope and connection. While ‘The Oath’ feels like a specific product of a politically charged era, ‘The Humans’ taps into a more timeless, and perhaps more terrifying, fear: that sometimes, families just fall apart under the simple, crushing weight of being human.













