The Grindhouse Experiment
To understand 'Thanksgiving,' you have to go back to 2007. Directors Quentin Tarantino and Robert Rodriguez released 'Grindhouse,' a double-feature love letter to the gritty, low-budget exploitation films of the 1970s. To complete the experience, they
invited friends like Roth, Rob Zombie, and Edgar Wright to create fake movie trailers to play between the two main features, 'Planet Terror' and 'Death Proof'. Roth, a lifelong horror fan, immediately knew what to do. He and his childhood friend, Jeff Rendell, had long lamented the lack of a true Thanksgiving-themed slasher movie, a gap in the holiday horror calendar dominated by Halloween and Christmas. Using crew and resources from his 'Hostel: Part II' shoot, Roth created a two-minute trailer for a movie that didn't exist: 'Thanksgiving'. It was a masterpiece of sleaze and gore, perfectly mimicking the grainy, over-the-top style of 1980s slasher previews, complete with a turkey mascot decapitation and a cheerleader meeting a gruesome end on a trampoline. It was an instant hit with fans, arguably becoming one of the most talked-about parts of the 'Grindhouse' experience.
A 16-Year Simmer in Pop Culture
The trailer was so effective that fans immediately began demanding a full-length movie. For years, it was the project Roth was most frequently asked about. He and Rendell had always intended to make a real movie, with the trailer essentially being a sizzle reel of their favorite kill ideas. Over the next decade and a half, the 'Thanksgiving' movie became a recurring rumor, a project perpetually in development. Roth would mention in interviews that they were working on a script, but the challenge was immense: how do you expand a two-minute joke filled with non-stop kills into a 90-minute story with characters and plot, without losing the spirit of the original? Other fake 'Grindhouse' trailers, like 'Machete' and 'Hobo with a Shotgun,' made the leap to the big screen, further fueling fan desire. Yet 'Thanksgiving' remained on the back burner, a cult classic promise that seemed like it might never be fulfilled. Roth admitted he felt guilt-tripped and shamed by the constant fan enthusiasm, which ultimately convinced him he had to make it happen.
From Joke to John Carver
The turning point came when Roth and Rendell devised a clever narrative framework. They decided to approach the new film as a modern reboot of a fictional, lost 1980s movie. This freed them from having to slavishly recreate every beat of the fake trailer. Instead, they could 'cherry pick' the best moments—like the iconic trampoline kill—and build a new story around them. The plot they developed centers on Plymouth, Massachusetts, the birthplace of the holiday, a year after a Black Friday riot at a superstore ends in tragedy. A mysterious killer, donning the mask of the colony's first governor, John Carver, begins terrorizing the town, seeking revenge on those he holds responsible for the deadly stampede. This new story allowed them to weave in social commentary about consumerism and class disparity, with Roth noting the dark irony of people being thankful one moment and trampling each other for a waffle iron the next.
Carving the Turkey, Finally
Released in November 2023, 'Thanksgiving' finally delivered on its 16-year-old promise. The film, shot in just 35 days on a tight budget, stars Patrick Dempsey, Addison Rae, and Rick Hoffman. While it features a modern high-definition look rather than the grainy 'Grindhouse' aesthetic, it fully embraces its slasher roots, paying homage to classics like 'Scream' and 'My Bloody Valentine'. Roth's goal was not just to extend the trailer, but to create a new, iconic slasher villain for a new generation. The film received generally positive reviews and was a box office success, grossing over $46 million worldwide on a $15 million budget. The journey from a two-minute gag to a profitable feature film was complete.













