The Gold Standard: Planes, Trains and Automobiles
Released in 1987, 'Planes, Trains and Automobiles' is not just the quintessential Thanksgiving movie; it's the gold standard for the 'unlikely companions on a disastrous journey' subgenre. Directed by John Hughes himself, the film pairs uptight advertising
executive Neal Page (Steve Martin) with the boorish but big-hearted shower curtain ring salesman Del Griffith (John Candy). Their three-day odyssey from New York to Chicago is a masterclass in comedic escalation, from a rerouted flight to a rental car fire. But its genius lies in its empathy. Neal is prickly and self-absorbed, while Del is a lonely force of nature masking deep pain. The comedy flows from their mismatched personalities, but the film’s enduring power comes from the slow, reluctant growth of their bond. Hughes balances slapstick with genuine pathos, culminating in a final act of compassion where Neal, finally home, realizes Del has nowhere to go and invites him to Thanksgiving dinner. It’s a story about seeing the humanity in someone you’d rather ignore, making it a timeless tale of connection.
The Grittier Rerun: Dutch
Four years later, in 1991, another John Hughes-penned script hit theaters with a remarkably similar premise. In 'Dutch,' working-class schlub Dutch Dooley (Ed O'Neill) volunteers to drive his wealthy girlfriend's snobbish, prep-school son, Doyle (Ethan Embry), from Georgia to Chicago for Thanksgiving. The goal is the same: get home for the holiday. The structure is familiar: a series of roadside mishaps and forced bonding. But the tone is drastically different. Where 'Planes, Trains and Automobiles' is warm-hearted underneath its frustration, 'Dutch' is cynical and often mean-spirited. The conflict isn't between two well-meaning but incompatible adults; it's between a man and a genuinely hateful child. Their initial interactions are surprisingly aggressive, setting a more abrasive and less charming tone. The film bombed at the box office and was poorly reviewed by critics, who saw it as a tired retread of Hughes's earlier, better work.
The John Hughes Blueprint
The most fascinating aspect of comparing the two films is that Hughes wrote both, essentially providing two drafts of the same idea. 'Planes, Trains and Automobiles' was a departure for him at the time, moving away from the teen comedies that made his name, like 'The Breakfast Club' and 'Ferris Bueller's Day Off'. It proved he could blend adult comedy with profound emotional depth. 'Dutch,' on the other hand, feels like an experiment gone slightly wrong. It attempts to explore class conflict more directly, pitting O'Neill's blue-collar decency against the entitled cruelty of the rich kid, Doyle. Yet the execution lacks the finesse of its predecessor. While Neal Page’s insults toward Del Griffith are a temporary lashing out from a man at his wit's end, the animosity in 'Dutch' feels more baked-in and sour. It’s as if Hughes tried to deconstruct his own formula, making the characters less immediately likable to see if the emotional payoff would still land.
Two Paths to the Same Destination
Ultimately, both films rework the holiday road trip by arguing that the journey is more important than the destination, and that true connection is the real homecoming. However, they reach that conclusion through different means. 'Planes, Trains and Automobiles' gets there through empathy and the gradual reveal of shared loneliness. Neal's transformation feels earned because Del, for all his flaws, is fundamentally a good person whom Neal learns to appreciate. In 'Dutch,' the bonding feels more like a product of shared trauma and exhaustion. Doyle only begins to soften after realizing his own father is a liar, and his turn toward decency feels abrupt after spending most of the film being relentlessly unpleasant. While 'Dutch' has gained a minor cult following as a Thanksgiving double-feature companion, it primarily serves to highlight what made 'Planes, Trains and Automobiles' so special: its perfect balance of humor and heart.













