The office cookie swap is a serious affair: the one true, socially acceptable, and pleasantly beneficial-to-all way to let your competitive streak shine in the workplace. There are multiple approaches, of course. Some of us like to have a signature contribution,
a recipe we’ve honed over years of practice so that everyone knows we’re your go-to person for ube crinkle cookies. Others of us try something new every year, hoping to wow our coworkers with that recipe they just keep seeing but haven’t gotten to try themselves. Of course, cookie season isn’t just about cookie swaps: Every home is made cozier by having a batch of cookies in the oven, even if it’s just for a personal midnight sweet treat or because a full cookie jar has restorative powers on a gray, cold day. Whatever your cookie needs may be, these are the recipes that Eater editors turn to time and time again.
Partner content from Amazon Grocery
Stack more, spend less. Amazon Grocery lets you spend less on all the people who eat your food. Shop Amazon for everyday low prices on groceries and get free same-day delivery with Prime.
Chocolate Salami
Dina Polyashov, Simply Home Cooked
I always learn about my new favorite cookie recipe at the annual Eater cookie swap. It’s how I first tasted Eric King’s stellar swirl cookies with Earl Grey and black sesame, and it’s also how I tried chocolate salami. My colleague Nick Mancall-Bitel always brings his A-game to the cookie swap, and one year, he required the very specific parameters of a recipe that didn’t involve baking. Chocolate salami — which does not involve the use of the latter ingredient in its name, but resembles it — is made by melting chocolate, adding crunchy ingredients like nuts and biscuits, then forming the mixture into a log shape. After the log sets and is dusted with powdered sugar, it can be cut into coins that resemble salami, and each one provides a satisfying array of textures. It’s as easy to make as Rice Krispies Treats, and since it doesn’t require use of the oven, it’s a great pick for an addition to a holiday cookie box, when you’re already playing the timing Tetris with other recipes. — Bettina Makalintal, senior reporter
Fifteens
Traybakes & More
I believe I first heard of fifteens on an episode of The Great British Bake-Off. Contestant Iain Ross made a Swiss roll inspired by the flavors of the traditional Irish dessert, a no-bake cookie made, simply, with 15 digestive biscuits, 15 marshmallows, and 15 cherries, combined with condensed milk and coconut. It sounded so easy, strange, and intriguing that I whipped up a batch myself (I believe that, fittingly, it only took about 15 total minutes of “cooking” time) and brought them to a British friend’s dinner party. The cookies serve as both a conversation piece (they’re kind of weird?) and a surprisingly craveable treat; the slightly salty crumb of the biscuits melds well with the fluffy marshmallow and syrupy cherries into a sort of sliceable, dense icebox cake. — Hilary Pollack, deputy editor
Angel Wings (Chruściki)
Judi Strauss, The Charmed Kitchen
My recipe for angel wings (or chruściki in Polish) comes from my grandmother, and it lives at my parents’ house, where it’s scrawled on the back of a weathered tax envelope. The cookie is made out of a crisp and light fried dough that is then sprinkled with powdered sugar. This recipe from the Charmed Kitchen comes pretty darn close to the one from Grandma, and calls for a whopping eight eggs and white wine to ensure that the dough fries up quickly without absorbing too much oil. These cookies make quite a visual impact on a holiday table — growing up, I loved it when my mom would stack the cooled wings on top of one another to create a tall, tangled nest. — Francky Knapp, staff writer
Peanut Butter & Jelly Linzer Bars
Megan Berger, The Berger Feed
I love linzer cookies, but I don’t have the patience to meticulously cut out and assemble each one. Last year for the holidays I made these linzer bars, which skip all the sandwiching while still feeling festive. Made with peanut butter and a little softer than a typical cookie, they’re like PB&Js as dessert. I appreciate that you can use whatever jam and cookie cutters you have on hand, too. — Mary Anne Porto, section editor, Punch
Eggnog Snickerdoodles
Vaughn Vreeland, NYT Cooking
I keep returning to Vaughn Vreeland’s eggnog Snickerdoodles recipe year after year. Snickerdoodles are such an underappreciated cookie in my opinion, and a great canvas for those really traditional winter flavors. These utilize freshly grated nutmeg instead of the traditional cinnamon. For extra nog-iness there’s a little rum extract in there, though I usually swap in a nice spiced rum instead. They’re lovely and crackly on the outside and soft and fudgy on the inside. As a bonus, these come together super fast and a single batch results in two dozen cookies, which makes them a great option if you’re filling up multiple gift boxes. — Brenna Houck, dining editorial manager
Ube Crinkle Cookies
Abi Balingit, The Dusky Kitchen
Any time I include these cookies in a holiday gift box or bring them to a party, people rave. There are so many things to love about them: the gorgeous purple hue, the melt-in-your-mouth powdered sugar coating, the unabashed ube flavor that is sweet and fragrant. For me, it’s not truly December until I am whipping up a batch of these cookies (and freezing some dough for my future self). And for those who are craving a single, giant cookie, Balingit includes a recipe for an ube crinkle skillet cookie in her debut cookbook, Mayumu. — Kat Thompson, audience editor, Southern California/Southeast
Zebra-Striped Shortbread Cookies
Chris Morocco, Bon Appétit
I love making Christmas cookies, even though I don’t have much of a sweet tooth. But even I can admit there’s just something about a sable cookie; nice texture, not too sweet — I particularly like this riff from Bon Appétit that they’ve christened Zebra-Striped Shortbread. They take some effort, but the swirl-like center design involves less precision than other, more fiddly counterparts. And the dusting of red and green sanding sugar offers a touch of festive classiness. These are cookies you can make in stages — prepare the doughs and chill overnight, handle the twisting, coating, and slicing another time. The result: a cookie that tastes good and is dressy enough for a holiday cocktail party. — Missy Frederick, editorial director
Pretzel Linzers with Salted Caramel
Deb Perelman, Bon Appétit
Linzers are persnickety, what with rolling the dough, cutting shapes, and prepping fillings. These pretzel caramel numbers are no exception, requiring bakers to also wedge a cutting board in their freezer and arrange cookie segments on cooling caramel. But they’re also very gratifying for the work. I first made them as part of an assorted holiday cookie tin, which was a mistake, both because the linzers require enough work to count as a standalone project and because they outshined every other cookie in the box. They’re salty and sweet, snappy and chewy. They deserve to shine on their own, and they make a great group activity. A food processor, a microwave, and enough room to spread out make the task a lot easier. — Nick Mancall-Bitel, dining and travel editorial manager






