An Invitation to Celebrate History
In 1970, the Commonwealth of Massachusetts was planning a grand celebration for the 350th anniversary of the Pilgrims' arrival. To add a touch of authenticity and apparent goodwill to a commemorative banquet, the organizers invited Wamsutta Frank James, an Aquinnah Wampanoag leader and schoolteacher, to give a speech. They envisioned a tribute that would reinforce the long-held myth of friendly relations and a harmonious first Thanksgiving between the colonists and the Native people who helped them survive. James accepted the invitation, seeing an opportunity to tell his people's story.
The Speech They Didn't Want to Hear
As was standard practice for such a high-profile event, the organizers asked James for an advance copy of his speech. What they received was not the gentle, appreciative
message they expected. Instead, James had written a powerful and historically grounded indictment of the Pilgrims and the devastating impact of colonization on the Wampanoag people. Citing historical sources, he wrote of graves being robbed, of corn and beans being stolen by the Pilgrims shortly after their arrival, and how the welcoming hand extended by the Wampanoag sachem Massasoit was the 'beginning of the end' for his people's freedom. He called out the 'history that was written by an organized, disciplined people, to expose us as an unorganized and undisciplined entity'.
A Refusal to Be Silenced
The state officials were alarmed. They deemed the speech too 'inflammatory' and 'inappropriate' to be delivered at a celebration. They told James he could not give the speech he had written. Instead, they offered to provide him with a sanitized version penned by a public relations professional—one that would align with the festive, conflict-free narrative of the evening. James refused. He would not have his voice censored or have false words put in his mouth. Rather than compromise, he withdrew from the banquet altogether. His act of defiance set the stage for an entirely different kind of commemoration.
The First Day of Mourning
On Thanksgiving Day 1970, instead of speaking at the state dinner, Wamsutta Frank James led a group of supporters and other Native people to Cole's Hill. The location was symbolic, overlooking Plymouth Rock and the statue of Massasoit, the very leader whose welcome had been so tragically repaid. There, James delivered his original, uncensored speech to the assembled crowd. That impromptu gathering of protest and remembrance was declared the first National Day of Mourning. Organized by the newly formed United American Indians of New England (UAINE), it transformed a moment of suppression into a powerful, enduring tradition.













