The Claim from Plymouth
The Thanksgiving narrative most Americans know and love is set in Plymouth, Massachusetts, in the autumn of 1621. After a brutal first winter that wiped out about half their population, the Pilgrims reaped a successful harvest. To celebrate, they held a three-day festival. The Plymouth colonists, along with a group of Wampanoag people, including their leader Massasoit, shared a feast of fowl, deer, and other bounty. This event is the bedrock of the modern American holiday—a story of gratitude, survival, and cooperation. It was a harvest festival, a secular celebration of a good crop that became a powerful symbol of American identity. However, it wasn't conceived as an annual, mandated event and was only later cemented in the national consciousness,
largely thanks to a 19th-century campaign by magazine editor Sarah Josepha Hale and President Abraham Lincoln's 1863 proclamation.
The Earlier Claim from Virginia
Travel back two years before the Plymouth feast, and 600 miles to the south, and you’ll find a different 'first Thanksgiving.' On December 4, 1619, a group of 38 English settlers led by Captain John Woodlief arrived at Berkeley Hundred (now Berkeley Plantation) on the banks of the James River in Virginia. Their journey across the Atlantic had been perilous. Upon their safe arrival, they followed a direct order from their London Company charter. The proclamation read: 'Wee ordaine that the day of our ships arrival...shall be yearly and perpetually kept holy as a day of thanksgiving to Almighty God.' This event was not a feast and did not involve Native Americans. It was a formal, religious service of thanks for safe passage, mandated to be an annual tradition.
It’s All in the Definition
So, who was first? The answer depends entirely on your definition of 'Thanksgiving.' If you define it as a harvest feast shared between European colonists and Native Americans, then Plymouth’s 1621 celebration is the clear precedent for our modern holiday meal. But if you define 'Thanksgiving' as the first officially proclaimed, annual day of thanks by English settlers, then the honor goes to Berkeley Plantation in 1619. The Berkeley event was a prescribed religious observance for safe arrival, while Plymouth’s was a spontaneous, secular feast celebrating a harvest. One was a solemn duty; the other was a communal party. Both have legitimate claims, but they are not claiming the same thing.
How Plymouth Won the PR War
For a long time, the Virginia claim was all but forgotten. The Berkeley Hundred settlement was attacked and abandoned during the Anglo-Powhatan War in 1622, and the annual tradition died with it. The records of this first Thanksgiving were lost until they were rediscovered in the 1930s. Meanwhile, the Plymouth story, with its compelling narrative of hardship and intercultural exchange, captured the American imagination. New England's cultural influence in shaping America's historical identity was immense. The story of the Pilgrims was taught in schools and elevated by presidential proclamations, becoming the version of events that lingered in the collective memory. Even after President John F. Kennedy acknowledged the Virginia claim in his 1963 Thanksgiving address, the Plymouth story has largely remained dominant.













