The Myth of the Friendly Feast
The story most Americans learn is of starving, grateful Pilgrims who, after a brutal first winter in 1620, were saved by benevolent Native Americans. The Wampanoag, a local tribe, taught them to plant corn and survive in the 'New World'. The following autumn, in 1621, the two groups supposedly sat down together for a harmonious three-day feast to celebrate the harvest—an event now called the 'First Thanksgiving'. This version portrays a peaceful beginning to a new nation, founded on mutual respect and cooperation. It's a comforting story, but it is a myth that glosses over the far more complex and painful truth.
An Alliance Born of Desperation
The 1621 gathering was not a simple dinner party; it was a political meeting. The Wampanoag leader, Ousamequin (also known as Massasoit),
did not form an alliance with the English colonists out of pure friendliness. His people had been devastated by a recent epidemic—the 'Great Dying'—likely introduced by European traders, which wiped out an estimated 70-90% of the coastal population. Weakened and vulnerable to their rivals, the Narragansett tribe, Ousamequin saw the well-armed English as potential, if risky, allies for tribal security. The interpreter who bridged the gap, Tisquantum (or Squanto), had his own traumatic history: he was a member of the Patuxet tribe who had been kidnapped, sold into slavery in Spain, and only returned to his homeland to find his entire village had been wiped out by disease. The Pilgrims had, in fact, built their settlement on the ruins of his village.
The True Cost of Colonization
The initial cooperation, born of mutual need, quickly soured. The story of the feast leaves out what came next: decades of dispossession. As more English colonists arrived, they brought with them an insatiable hunger for land. What started as a small Plymouth settlement expanded into a wave of colonization that pushed the Wampanoag and other Indigenous peoples from their ancestral territories. The English worldview of private land ownership clashed with Indigenous concepts of communal use, leading to countless conflicts, broken agreements, and the steady erosion of Native sovereignty. This systematic seizure of land and resources is the unspoken cost at the heart of the Thanksgiving story.
From Feast to All-Out War
The fragile peace shattered completely within a single generation. In 1675, Ousamequin’s own son, Metacom (known to the English as King Philip), led a pan-tribal uprising against the colonists in a desperate attempt to reclaim their lands and way of life. The conflict, known as King Philip's War, was devastating. It is considered by some historians to be the deadliest war in American history on a per-capita basis. The war ended in defeat for the Native alliance. Metacom was killed, dismembered, and his head was displayed on a spike in Plymouth for over two decades as a warning. Many Native survivors were sold into slavery. This brutal conflict was the direct and tragic legacy of the encounter that began with the supposed 'peaceful' feast.
A National Day of Mourning
For many Native Americans, Thanksgiving is not a day of celebration. Since 1970, the United American Indians of New England have organized a 'National Day of Mourning' on Cole's Hill in Plymouth, overlooking Plymouth Rock. It is a day of remembrance for the millions of Indigenous people who suffered and died as a result of European colonization, and a protest against the ongoing racism and oppression they face. The event began after Wamsutta (Frank) James, a Wampanoag man, was invited to speak at a 350th anniversary celebration of the Pilgrims' landing, but his truthful, critical speech was censored by organizers. Choosing to tell the full story is a vital step in honoring this history.













