1. Check the Clothing and Colors
The classic image of English colonists in black suits with large white collars and buckled hats is a 19th-century invention. In reality, the Plymouth colonists, or 'Separatists' as they called themselves, wore colorful clothing made with plant-based dyes. Black dye was expensive and reserved for formal occasions. Buckles on hats and shoes were not in fashion. Likewise, depictions of Wampanoag men in large, feathered war bonnets are inaccurate; those were characteristic of Plains nations and not worn by the peoples of the Northeast Woodlands, like the Wampanoag. Wampanoag attire would have consisted of deerskin breechcloths, leggings, and mantles.
2. Check the Narrative It Conveys
Does the image portray a simple, peaceful dinner between two equal groups of friends? This popular
narrative is misleading. The 1621 harvest gathering was more likely a tense diplomatic event driven by mutual need, not a simple invitation. The Wampanoag, led by their sachem Ousamequin (also known as Massasoit), had been devastated by disease introduced by earlier European contact and saw an alliance with the English as a strategic move against rival tribes. The English, having barely survived their first winter, desperately needed local knowledge and stability. The image of a harmonious feast often erases this complex political reality and the violent conflicts that followed in subsequent decades.
3. Check the People and Proportions
Many paintings show a small, friendly group of Native Americans joining a larger Pilgrim contingent. Historical accounts suggest the opposite was true. Edward Winslow, a colonist who was present, wrote that Ousamequin arrived with some 90 men, who then feasted with the roughly 50 surviving colonists for three days. The Wampanoag significantly outnumbered the English. Some historians suggest the Wampanoag showed up not because they were invited, but because they heard celebratory gunfire and came to investigate, fearing an attack. An image that minimizes the Wampanoag presence or portrays them as passive guests misrepresents the power dynamics of the moment.
4. Check the Food on the Table
Your classic Thanksgiving spread of turkey, pumpkin pie, mashed potatoes, and cranberry sauce is not what was served in 1621. While wild fowl was on the menu—and Governor William Bradford mentioned a 'great store of wild turkeys'—it was likely accompanied by other birds like duck and geese. The main course was venison, with the Wampanoag having contributed five deer. Seafood like eel, lobster, clams, and mussels was also abundant and likely eaten. There were no potatoes, and without flour or butter, there was no pie. Pumpkins and other squashes were likely served, but not in a sweet dessert form.
5. Check the Names and Terminology
Generic labels like 'Pilgrims' and 'Indians' flatten history. The English settlers at Plymouth did not call themselves Pilgrims; they were 'Separatists' or 'Old Comers'. The term 'Pilgrim' became popular in the 19th century. More importantly, the Native people present were not a generic group of 'Indians'. They were the Wampanoag, a specific nation with its own distinct culture and history. Using the correct names—'English colonists' and 'Wampanoag'—is a fundamental step toward historical accuracy and showing respect. It acknowledges that the Wampanoag are a living people with a history that existed long before 1620 and continues today.
6. Check the Image's Origin
Virtually all popular paintings of the 'First Thanksgiving,' like those by Jean Leon Gerome Ferris and Jennie Augusta Brownscombe, were created in the late 19th or early 20th centuries. These images were not historical documents but romanticized creations intended to forge a national origin story. At a time of high immigration and national anxiety after the Civil War, this myth of a peaceful, bloodless founding served to unify white, Anglo-Saxon Americans and gloss over the violent realities of colonization. Knowing an image is a modern myth rather than a historical record is crucial context.
7. Check for an Indigenous Perspective
Does the way you're using the image acknowledge the Wampanoag perspective? For many Native Americans, Thanksgiving is not a celebration but a National Day of Mourning. This commemoration, started in 1970, remembers the genocide of millions of Native people, the theft of their lands, and the assault on their cultures that followed colonization. When using a historical image, consider pairing it with content that includes this viewpoint, highlights the Wampanoag's central role, or directs audiences to resources created by Indigenous educators and museums. This provides a more complete and honest account of the holiday's complex legacy.













