The Tradition Isn't Ancient History
Contrary to popular belief, the formal, annual turkey pardon is a surprisingly modern invention. While stories circulate about Abraham Lincoln sparing a Christmas turkey in 1863 at his son's request, this was a one-off event. Many also credit Harry S. Truman with starting the tradition in 1947, but records from his presidential library show he had no problem eating the turkeys he received. Sporadic acts of clemency occurred over the years; John F. Kennedy sent a turkey back to a farm in 1963, simply saying, 'Let's keep him going'. But the official, institutionalized ceremony we know today was started by President George H.W. Bush in 1989. Facing animal rights protestors, he declared that the bird presented to him was 'granted a Presidential
pardon as of right now,' and every president has followed suit since.
They Aren't Really 'Pardoned'
The term 'pardon' is itself a piece of political theater. A legal pardon absolves an individual of a crime. These turkeys, of course, are guilty of nothing more than being delicious. The term first entered the lexicon as a joke. In 1987, during the Iran-Contra affair, President Ronald Reagan was peppered with questions about whether he would pardon key figures. When asked about the turkey, he deflected with humor, saying he would pardon the bird. President George H.W. Bush solidified the term in 1989, but even he acknowledged its absurdity, saying, ''Reprieve', 'keep him going', or 'pardon': it's all the same for the turkey'. The act is purely ceremonial and carries no legal weight; it's a public reprieve, not a formal exoneration for a feathered felon.
The Turkeys Are Chosen Like Pageant Contestants
The two turkeys that arrive in Washington D.C. are not chosen at random. They are the winners of a lengthy and deliberate selection process run by the National Turkey Federation. A 'presidential flock' of about 50 birds is raised, often in the home state of the current NTF chairman. These birds are specially handled from a young age to acclimate them to crowds, bright lights, and loud noises to ensure they remain calm during the ceremony. From this flock, the two best-behaved and best-looking birds are selected to travel to the capital. They are judged on their temperament, appearance, and ability to handle the stress of the media event, ensuring the president gets a photogenic and cooperative co-star.
A Long Life Isn't Guaranteed
While spared from the Thanksgiving table, the pardoned turkeys do not live out long, idyllic lives. These are Broad Breasted White turkeys, a breed specifically developed for the meat industry. They are bred to grow exceptionally large and fast, and their bodies often can't support their own weight. This leads to a host of health problems, including heart failure and leg issues. Consequently, most pardoned turkeys live for less than a year or two after their moment in the Rose Garden spotlight. After the ceremony, the birds are sent to live at universities or historical farms—such as Virginia Tech, Purdue University, or Iowa State University—where they are cared for but rarely survive long.
The 'Understudy' Turkey Is Safe, Too
Every year, two turkeys make the trip to Washington: a primary turkey and an alternate, or 'understudy'. While only one bird stands next to the president during the official ceremony, both are spared from the dinner table. This is a practical measure in case the main bird becomes ill or is otherwise unable to perform its duties. After the press conference and photo opportunities—which sometimes include a luxurious stay at the Willard InterContinental Hotel—both turkeys are sent to the same retirement location to live out the remainder of their short lives together. So while one gets the official title, both get the same prize: a pass for Thanksgiving.













