An Alarming Experiment in Jodhpur
A recent undercover investigation by the Dainik Bhaskar newspaper has sent ripples of concern through India’s vast jewellery market. According to reports, investigators in Jodhpur, Rajasthan, conducted an experiment to test a worrying claim: that gold
could be adulterated with a heavy metal powder and still pass multiple purity checks, including official hallmarking. They reportedly mixed one gram of rhenium powder into just under eight grams of 24-carat gold. The resulting ornament, which should have been around 20-carat purity, was then taken to various testing centres and showrooms. Shockingly, the investigation claimed that the adulterated piece was repeatedly certified as 22-carat (91.6% pure) gold, and even received an official 916 hallmark. While the experiment has not been independently verified by government labs, it exposes a potential vulnerability that could be exploited to defraud consumers.
What is Rhenium and Why is It a Problem?
Rhenium is a silvery-grey metal that is one of the rarest elements on Earth, primarily used in high-performance industrial applications like jet engine turbine blades. Its key properties make it a uniquely problematic adulterant for gold. First, its density is very close to that of gold—in fact, it's slightly denser. This means traditional weight and density checks, which might catch lighter adulterants, can be easily fooled. Second, it has an extremely high melting point and is resistant to corrosion, allowing it to survive the jewellery-making process. Most critically, its atomic properties cause its signal to overlap with gold's during analysis by some common X-ray fluorescence (XRF) machines, which are the 'karatmeters' used in many showrooms and hallmarking centres. This can lead the machine to misread the rhenium as gold, reporting a higher purity than is actually present.
The Challenge to Hallmarking
The Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) hallmark is the bedrock of consumer trust in the gold industry, certifying the purity of an ornament. The system relies on a network of Assaying and Hallmarking Centres (AHCs) to test jewellery. However, the reported Rajasthan experiment suggests that some of these centres, possibly using older or improperly calibrated XRF machines, might not be equipped to detect this specific type of sophisticated adulteration. The issue isn't that rhenium is entirely undetectable; advanced, high-resolution spectrometers can distinguish it. The problem is that these machines are not universally used across the thousands of testing centres and retail stores in the country. The incident also raises questions about surveillance, with a draft CAG report noting that a large percentage of registered jewellers and hallmarking centres were not inspected in the 2024-25 period.
What Does This Mean for Consumers?
The financial implications of such a scam are significant. Based on the ratios used in the Jodhpur experiment, an ornament certified as 22-carat could actually have a purity closer to 20-carat. At current gold prices, this could result in a direct loss of thousands of rupees for a customer buying just 10 grams of gold. While there is no evidence yet of widespread use of rhenium in the Indian market, the revelation serves as a critical warning. For now, consumers must remain vigilant. The first line of defence is to always insist on hallmarked jewellery bearing the three official marks: the BIS logo, the purity grade (e.g., 22K916), and the six-character alphanumeric Hallmark Unique Identification (HUID) number. This HUID can be verified using the BIS Care app to check the jeweller's details and the item's purity.
The Path Forward for the Industry
The reported scam is a wake-up call for the entire gold industry, from refiners to retailers. It highlights an urgent need to update and standardize testing protocols to keep pace with evolving adulteration techniques. This may involve mandating the use of higher-resolution XRF machines equipped with software capable of specifically identifying elements like rhenium, iridium, and osmium, which have also been used as adulterants. For consumers, the immediate advice is to buy from reputable, well-established jewellers and always demand a proper, GST-compliant invoice detailing the weight, purity, and HUID of the ornament. If there is any doubt about an item's purity, it can be tested at a BIS-recognised hallmarking centre. This incident underscores that while hallmarks remain the best available guarantee, the system that supports them requires constant evolution to protect the trust of millions of Indian buyers.















