What's Happening?
The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) has rescinded its 2012 Enforcement Guidance on the Consideration of Arrest and Conviction Records in Employment Decisions under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act. This decision, made on October 29,
2026, signals a shift in the agency's approach to how employers evaluate applicants' criminal histories. The 2012 guidance had previously cautioned employers against automatically excluding applicants based on criminal records, as such policies could disproportionately affect individuals based on race or national origin. It encouraged individualized assessments, considering the nature and severity of an offense, the time elapsed, and its relevance to the position. By rescinding this guidance, the EEOC has withdrawn these specific recommendations, potentially offering employers more flexibility. However, employers are not mandated to discontinue existing screening practices that comply with applicable laws, and the underlying federal anti-discrimination laws remain in effect.
Why It's Important?
This rescission is significant because it alters federal enforcement guidance, potentially influencing how employers structure their hiring policies regarding criminal background checks. While the EEOC has withdrawn its specific recommendations for individualized assessments, employers still bear the responsibility to comply with Title VII of the Civil Rights Act, which prohibits discrimination based on race, national origin, or other protected characteristics. This means that screening policies could still face disparate impact challenges if they disproportionately exclude protected groups without proper justification. Furthermore, state and local restrictions on criminal background screening remain fully in effect, meaning employers in many jurisdictions, such as Illinois and Chicago, must continue to adhere to specific laws like 'Ban-the-Box' legislation and individualized assessment requirements. The Fair Credit Reporting Act (FCRA) requirements for employers using third-party screening companies also remain unchanged, ensuring continued protections for applicants.
What's Next?
Employers are advised to review their existing background screening policies to ensure continued legal compliance rather than making immediate, sweeping changes. The rescission does not grant permission for unrestricted criminal background screening. Employers should confirm that any criminal history exclusions are tied to legitimate business considerations and are appropriate for the specific positions. Avoiding blanket exclusions for any criminal record, regardless of its relevance, remains a prudent risk-management practice. Maintaining individualized assessments, even if no longer explicitly recommended by the EEOC, is still crucial where required by state and local laws and can serve as an important risk-management tool. Employers operating across multiple jurisdictions must ensure their procedures, adverse action notices, and hiring personnel training comply with all applicable federal, state, and local laws, applying screening standards consistently.
Beyond the Headlines
The EEOC's decision to rescind its 2012 guidance highlights the ongoing tension between employer flexibility in hiring and the imperative to prevent employment discrimination. While the move may be seen by some as reducing regulatory burden on businesses, it places a greater onus on employers to understand and navigate a complex patchwork of federal, state, and local laws. The long-term implications could include an increase in litigation challenging employer screening practices under disparate impact theories, as the absence of specific EEOC guidance might lead some employers to adopt more restrictive policies. This development also underscores the evolving nature of employment law and the need for continuous vigilance from employers to ensure their practices are both effective for business needs and compliant with anti-discrimination principles, particularly concerning historically marginalized groups who may be disproportionately affected by criminal background checks.













