What's Happening?
A recent analysis by Wyoming Game and Fish Department disease biologist Ben Wise has debunked a common argument used to justify continued elk feeding operations despite the spread of Chronic Wasting Disease (CWD). The argument, often made by hunting outfitters
and others resistant to changing Wyoming's historic elk feeding system, suggested that elk herds would remain healthy even with CWD, citing the Laramie Peak Herd as an example. Wise's research compared the winter home ranges of free-roaming elk in the Laramie Mountains with those of elk gathered at state-run feedgrounds and the National Elk Refuge. The analysis revealed a dramatic difference: free-roaming elk had a median core winter home range of 1,959 acres, while feedground elk had a median core winter home range of just 6 acres. This significant difference in spatial distribution means that feedground elk are far more susceptible to disease transmission due to their high density in confined areas, making comparisons to free-ranging herds invalid.
Why It's Important?
This analysis is crucial for wildlife management in Wyoming, particularly concerning the state's 21 elk feedgrounds and the National Elk Refuge. CWD is a fatal neurological disease, and its spread in dense elk populations at feedgrounds poses a severe threat to herd health and long-term hunting opportunities. The debunking of the 'Laramie Peak' argument provides critical data to support adjustments to feedground operations, which are currently under review. Wildlife disease experts predict a much poorer outlook for feedground herds compared to free-ranging ones, with populations and hunting opportunities expected to plummet if current feeding practices continue. The research underscores the need for strategies that encourage elk dispersal and reduce density during winter feeding periods, aiming to mitigate the impact of CWD and preserve the health of these iconic wildlife populations.
What's Next?
The Wyoming Game and Fish Department will utilize Wise's analysis as it continues to adjust its feedground operations. The state agency is actively developing 'feedground management action plans' for various elk herds. Plans for the Jackson and Pinedale herds have already been completed, outlining specific steps to reduce CWD impact. Action plans for the remaining four feedground elk herds—Fall Creek, Afton, Piney, and Upper Green—are slated for completion this winter, with a commitment to finish by early 2027. These plans will likely explore techniques to increase elk distribution on the landscape and reduce overall density during active feeding periods. The state has already seen some success with expanding feedground areas, such as at the Horse Creek Feedground, indicating that elk will utilize larger areas if food is available. The governor now holds the authority to close a feedground, a power previously held by the Wyoming Legislature.
Beyond the Headlines
The findings from Wyoming's elk CWD analysis extend beyond immediate wildlife management to touch upon broader ecological and societal implications. The study highlights the complex interplay between human intervention (feedgrounds), wildlife behavior, and disease ecology. It underscores the unintended consequences of long-standing management practices that, while initially intended to support wildlife, can create conditions ripe for disease transmission. This situation also brings to light the challenges of balancing diverse stakeholder interests, such as those of hunting outfitters who benefit from concentrated elk populations, with the long-term health and sustainability of wildlife. Ethically, it raises questions about human responsibility in managing wildlife populations and the need for adaptive strategies based on scientific evidence, even when those strategies challenge traditional practices. The outcome of Wyoming's feedground adjustments could serve as a model or cautionary tale for other regions grappling with similar wildlife disease issues.













