What's Happening?
A Jackson-based developer, Cardinal Lands, plans to demolish the downtown Knit on Pearl block to construct 39,500 square feet of high-end short-term rentals and market-rate condominiums. This redevelopment will displace several local businesses, including
the crafting shop Knit on Pearl, the state’s unemployment office, and One22’s Jackson Cupboard food pantry. According to Cardinal Lands managing partner Albert Nichols, the proposed homes will not be deed-restricted, and no first-floor space will be reserved for commercial renters, citing the difficulty in finding tenants who can afford the cost of building such spaces. Tenants have varying lease durations, and Nichols stated that contracts would be extended as needed. This project is Cardinal Lands' first in Jackson, following two high-end communities developed in Driggs, Idaho.
Why It's Important?
This development highlights a significant challenge facing many U.S. downtown areas: the displacement of long-standing local businesses due to high-end redevelopment. The conversion of commercial spaces into luxury residential units, particularly short-term rentals, can erode the unique character and community services of a neighborhood. Businesses like Knit on Pearl, which has been a local fixture for 30 years, and essential services like a food pantry and unemployment office, are vital for the community's social and economic fabric. The lack of deed-restricted units and commercial space in the new development suggests a focus on maximizing profit over community needs, potentially leading to a less diverse and less accessible downtown. This trend can exacerbate affordability issues for both residents and businesses, making it difficult for local workers to live and operate in the area, and ultimately impacting the local economy and social equity.
What's Next?
A public meeting regarding the proposed demolition and redevelopment is scheduled for Tuesday, November 24, at the Teton County Library. This meeting will provide an opportunity for community feedback, though developer Albert Nichols has indicated that significant changes, such as adding commercial or deed-restricted units, are not expected. The Jackson Town Council recently voted to ban first-floor residential development in a certain portion of downtown to combat the displacement of local businesses. The Cardinal Lands project could be affected if this rule takes effect before the project reaches a certain stage. Local business owners, such as Melissa Wandurski of All About You Barber, are expressing concern about their ability to restart elsewhere, while others, like Knit on Pearl owner Margaret Brady, are seeking new, larger spaces. The Wyoming Department of Workforce Services is also searching for a replacement office for the unemployment services.
Beyond the Headlines
The planned demolition of the Knit on Pearl block for high-end rentals in Jackson reflects a broader tension between economic development and community preservation in rapidly gentrifying areas across the U.S. The developer's rationale that commercial spaces are not viable due to high construction costs underscores a market-driven approach that often prioritizes luxury residential over local commerce and essential services. This raises ethical questions about the responsibility of developers and local governments to maintain a balanced urban ecosystem. The struggle of small businesses to afford space in downtown areas, as articulated by Chris Denny of Denny, ink., points to a systemic issue where the cost of living and operating outpaces local wages. The Town Council's move to ban first-floor residential development in parts of downtown indicates a growing recognition of this problem, but its effectiveness will depend on timely implementation and broader policy changes. This situation highlights the ongoing debate about who benefits from urban redevelopment and the long-term cultural impact of losing unique, community-serving establishments.













