What's Happening?
Shelby Miller, a right-handed pitcher, recently underwent elbow surgery to repair his ulnar collateral ligament and flexor tendon, as reported by MLB.com. This procedure is expected to sideline him for
the entire 2026 season. Miller's arm issues have been a recurring problem throughout the 2025 season. He initially went on the injured list in July due to a forearm strain while playing for the Diamondbacks. Despite being on the injured list, he was traded to the Brewers, who were aware of the risks involved. After returning from the injured list in mid-August, Miller experienced a 'pop' in his elbow in September, leading to a diagnosis of a sprained UCL and a subsequent placement on the 60-day injured list. At 35 years old, Miller faces a challenging recovery, especially considering this is his second Tommy John surgery.
Why It's Important?
Miller's surgery and subsequent absence from the 2026 season have significant implications for his career and the teams involved. As an impending free agent, his market value is likely to be affected, with teams potentially hesitant to offer long-term contracts due to his age and injury history. The situation highlights the risks teams take when acquiring players with known health issues. For the Brewers, the trade for Miller was a calculated risk, as they did not give up any prospect capital, instead taking on a financial commitment. The broader impact on the league includes the potential for other teams to reassess their strategies when dealing with players with similar injury histories.
What's Next?
Miller's future in Major League Baseball remains uncertain. While pitchers in similar situations sometimes receive two-year contracts to allow for rehabilitation, Miller's age and the fact that this is his second UCL surgery may deter teams from making such offers. His recovery and rehabilitation will be closely monitored, and his ability to return to his previous performance levels will be crucial in determining his career trajectory. Meanwhile, the Brewers and other teams will continue to evaluate their rosters and potential acquisitions as they prepare for the upcoming season.
