What's Happening?
Simcocks Advocates, a law firm based in Douglas, has raised significant concerns regarding the proposed Area Plan for the North and West, which is set to be reviewed by Tynwald. The firm, representing Baccarat Limited, argues that the plan is based on outdated
data and lacks independence, making it potentially undeliverable. The plan, according to Simcocks, was developed without an updated National Infrastructure Strategy, which was last published in 2018. This strategy had already highlighted congestion issues at key junctions into Douglas, such as Governor’s Dip and Quarterbridge, which are operating at over 85% capacity. The firm also questions the adequacy of consultations with other departments like Highways, Health and Social Care, and Education, Culture and Sport. Simcocks further alleges a conflict of interest due to the Cabinet Office's dual role in drafting the plan and administering the public inquiry, and criticizes the lack of independent Terms of Reference for the inquiry.
Why It's Important?
The concerns raised by Simcocks Advocates highlight potential flaws in the planning process that could have significant implications for the Isle of Man's development strategy. If the plan is based on outdated data and lacks proper consultation, it could lead to infrastructure challenges, particularly in managing traffic congestion and supporting population growth. The alleged conflict of interest and lack of independence in the planning process could undermine public trust and the effectiveness of governance. This situation underscores the importance of transparency and thorough consultation in urban planning to ensure sustainable growth and connectivity, aligning with the Isle of Man Strategic Plan 2016.
What's Next?
The Isle of Man Government has been approached for comment, and it remains to be seen how Tynwald members will respond to the concerns raised by Simcocks Advocates. The firm urges that any order brought before Tynwald should demonstrate a sound process, reliable data, and alignment with government policy before approval. The outcome of this review could influence future planning processes and governance practices on the Isle of Man, potentially leading to revisions in the proposed plan to address the highlighted issues.
