What's Happening?
A debate within the Jewish community has emerged, focusing on the balance between security and community engagement. Bret Stephens, in his 'State of World Jewry' address, questioned the readiness of institutions like the Anti-Defamation League to handle
modern antisemitism. Jonathan Greenblatt emphasized the need for robust security infrastructure while maintaining Jewish identity and community strength. The discussion highlights the structural challenges within American Jewish philanthropy, where security and engagement are often treated as separate priorities. The call is for a more integrated approach, where security and vibrant community life are seen as interdependent, fostering a resilient Jewish civil society.
Why It's Important?
This debate is crucial as it addresses the sustainability of Jewish life in the diaspora, where security and community engagement must coexist to ensure resilience. The integration of these elements is vital for maintaining a strong Jewish identity and combating antisemitism effectively. By fostering a dense and networked community, Jewish civil society can enhance its influence and cultural standing, which is essential for shaping allies and deterring adversaries. The discussion also reflects broader societal challenges of balancing security with cultural and community development, a theme relevant to many minority communities globally.
