What's Happening?
The Shawnee Council Committee has directed city staff to amend its co-living ordinance, which previously restricted the number of unrelated individuals living together in a single household. The current ordinance, enacted in April 2022, limits unrelated residents
to three or fewer. The proposed changes would increase this limit to a maximum of four unrelated people. Additionally, the committee plans to remove a rule that classified an entire household as unrelated if even one adult resident was not related to the others. This ordinance had drawn national criticism, being dubbed a 'ban on roommates,' and led to a federal lawsuit filed in May 2023 by Shawnee resident Val French and HomeRoom, Inc. Although the lawsuit was dismissed by a federal appeals court and the U.S. Supreme Court declined to hear the case, the city spent approximately $27,000 defending it. City Attorney Jenny Smith noted that with the legal case resolved, the city is now in a position to re-evaluate the ordinance.
Why It's Important?
This move by the Shawnee Council Committee is significant for housing affordability and individual living arrangements in the city. The original ordinance, which was intended to address issues like out-of-town investors buying properties and converting them into multi-tenant rentals, inadvertently restricted options for residents facing high housing costs. Councilmembers Steele Reynolds, Erin Aldridge, and Jeanie Murphy all expressed concerns about the impact of the current restrictions on residents' ability to afford housing. The Pacific Legal Foundation, which represented the plaintiffs in the lawsuit, argued that such restrictions make housing affordability more difficult by limiting who can live together in single-family homes. Easing these restrictions could provide more flexible and affordable housing solutions for individuals and families in Shawnee, potentially benefiting students, young professionals, and others seeking to share living expenses. Conversely, some residents who supported the original ban, citing concerns about traffic and neighborhood complaints, might view these changes with apprehension.
What's Next?
The process for amending the co-living ordinance will involve several steps. City Attorney Jenny Smith indicated that the Shawnee Planning Commission is expected to take up the proposed amendments in December or early 2027. Following the Planning Commission's review and recommendations, the Shawnee City Council will then vote on the changes. If approved, these amendments would officially modify the city's municipal code regarding co-living arrangements. The outcome will determine the future landscape of shared housing in Shawnee and could influence similar discussions in other municipalities grappling with housing affordability and zoning regulations. The decision will be closely watched by housing advocates, property management companies, and residents.
Beyond the Headlines
The Shawnee co-living ordinance and its potential amendment highlight a broader tension between municipal control over residential living and individual housing choices, particularly in the context of rising housing costs. The initial ban reflected a desire by some city officials to preserve neighborhood character and address perceived nuisances associated with higher-density living in single-family zones. However, the backlash and legal challenges underscore a growing societal need for flexible housing solutions. The 'Golden Girls' analogy used by Councilmember Jeanie Murphy points to the cultural shift towards diverse household compositions beyond traditional nuclear families. This situation also touches upon the legal boundaries of local government intervention in private living arrangements and the balance between community standards and individual liberties. The eventual resolution in Shawnee could set a precedent for how other U.S. cities approach similar challenges, potentially influencing future urban planning and housing policies nationwide.













