What's Happening?
The Karoo Donkey Sanctuary is calling on South Africa's Agriculture Minister Willie Aucamp to implement the African Union (AU) moratorium on slaughtering donkeys for their skins and to publish a clear timetable for ending the trade. The sanctuary highlights
the devastating impact of the global demand for ejiao, a gelatin made from donkey hides used in traditional Chinese medicine, beauty, and wellness products. The Donkey Sanctuary UK estimates that at least 5.9 million donkeys are slaughtered worldwide annually for this trade. China's donkey population has drastically declined, leading the industry to seek supplies from Africa, Asia, and South America. The Karoo Donkey Sanctuary argues that continued commercial slaughter exposes donkeys to immense suffering and threatens the livelihoods of families dependent on these animals for transport. In February 2024, AU leaders agreed to a moratorium, and the AU’s Inter-African Bureau for Animal Resources (AU-IBAR) has since urged stronger national implementation and enforcement against illegal slaughter and trafficking.
Why It's Important?
The call for South Africa to implement the AU moratorium is crucial for animal welfare and the socio-economic stability of rural communities. The brutal trade in donkey skins involves severe animal suffering, including long-distance transport without adequate food or water, and inhumane slaughter practices. Beyond animal cruelty, the trade has significant human impact; when donkeys are stolen or lost, households lose an essential means of transporting water, food, and agricultural goods, directly affecting their ability to sustain themselves. South Africa's current 'controlled export model' with an annual benchmark of 10,500 donkey hides is seen by advocates as insufficient, as it regulates rather than ends the commercial slaughter. Implementing the moratorium would align South Africa with a continental effort to protect donkeys and support vulnerable communities, setting a precedent for other nations facing similar pressures from the skin trade.
What's Next?
The Karoo Donkey Sanctuary is specifically asking the Department of Agriculture to publish a timetable for implementing the AU moratorium in South Africa, end the commercial slaughter of donkeys for their skins and associated exports, and provide transparency on current export authorizations, slaughter figures, and oversight authorities. They also advocate for strengthened enforcement against cruelty, theft, illegal slaughter, and trafficking, alongside humane handling education for donkey owners and traders. The Department of Agriculture has acknowledged the AU's continental position and moratorium, stating that it is calling on member states for progressive implementation. However, it has not provided a timeline or draft schedule. The department indicated that donkey welfare and the implications of the AU moratorium are being considered as animal welfare policies and legislation are reformed and updated. Future developments will depend on the government's response to these demands and its commitment to enacting the AU's directive.
Beyond the Headlines
The donkey skin trade highlights a complex intersection of animal welfare, economic demand, traditional medicine, and international policy. The rapid decline in donkey populations globally, driven by demand for ejiao, underscores the unsustainable nature of this trade. This issue also brings to light the challenges of enforcing international agreements at a national level, particularly when economic interests are involved. The call for transparency in export figures and oversight mechanisms points to broader governance issues within the agricultural sector. Furthermore, the plight of donkeys reflects a wider concern about the exploitation of animals for commercial purposes, often with little regard for their welfare or ecological impact. The success of the AU moratorium in South Africa could serve as a model for other countries grappling with similar wildlife and animal product trades, emphasizing the importance of ethical considerations and sustainable practices in global commerce.













