What's Happening?
Fix the Court has established a new database to track the financial disclosure reports of circuit judges from 2021 to 2025. This initiative aims to assess the judiciary's adherence to a 2022 law mandating online posting of judges' disclosures. As of the second
posting deadline on November 12, 2026, 87.1% of the 272 active or senior circuit judges had their 2025 reports in the database, meaning 237 disclosures were available. However, 35 circuit judges' disclosures are still missing, with 10 of these originating from the Third Circuit. Overall, 93.4% of the 2,200 judges required to file had their 2025 disclosures posted by November 13, a significant improvement from the previous year when only about half of the 2024 reports were available.
Why It's Important?
The creation of this database and the findings are crucial for transparency and public trust in the US judiciary. Financial disclosures help ensure judges are aware of their potential conflicts of interest and recusal obligations, preventing them from ruling on cases where they have a financial or personal stake. The missing disclosures raise concerns about accountability and the potential for undisclosed conflicts, which could undermine the integrity of judicial proceedings. This effort by Fix the Court highlights the ongoing challenge of achieving full compliance with transparency laws within the judicial branch and emphasizes the need for external oversight to ensure adherence to ethical standards.
What's Next?
Fix the Court expects the judiciary to maintain or improve its diligence in fulfilling statutory obligations for posting disclosures online in future years. The organization is advocating for Congress to pass a stock ban that includes the judiciary, which would likely increase the workload for the Administrative Office of the US Courts' Committee on Financial Disclosure due to the need for stock transaction reports. Fix the Court has reached out to judges with missing disclosures and their circuit executives to address the delays. The organization also notes that while judges can request redactions for security reasons, the process for approving these requests should not take six months, and judges should file their reports earlier in the year.
Beyond the Headlines
The persistent issues with judicial financial disclosures, despite a 2022 law designed to improve transparency, point to deeper systemic challenges within the judiciary regarding accountability and self-regulation. The fact that the judiciary initially lobbied for a much longer implementation period for an online database suggests a reluctance to embrace immediate transparency. This situation raises questions about the balance between judicial independence and public oversight. The ongoing efforts by organizations like Fix the Court are vital in pushing for greater transparency, which is essential for maintaining public confidence in the impartiality and fairness of the justice system. The debate over a stock ban for judges further highlights the ethical complexities and the need for robust mechanisms to prevent conflicts of interest.













