What's Happening?
Arizona has been ranked as the top state in the 2026 Health Freedom Index, with Colorado following as number two, according to Jared Rhoads, founder and executive director of the Center for Modern Health. This index, developed in collaboration with the Knee
Regulatory Research Center, evaluates all 50 U.S. states and Washington, D.C., across 54 policy variables. These variables are categorized into professional, institutional, patient, payment, and delivery freedom. The findings indicate that health policy performance does not align strictly with traditional red or blue state political classifications. States like Idaho, North Dakota, and Utah also ranked high, while New Jersey, Massachusetts, New York, and Rhode Island were at the bottom of the list. Rhoads emphasized that the primary goal of the index is not merely to create a leaderboard but to identify policy areas that are not inherently partisan, offering opportunities for cross-political collaboration and improvement in healthcare policies nationwide.
Why It's Important?
The Health Freedom Index challenges the conventional understanding of how political affiliations influence healthcare policy outcomes. By demonstrating that both traditionally 'red' and 'blue' states can excel in health freedom, the index suggests that effective healthcare policy is not solely dictated by partisan ideologies. This has significant implications for U.S. public policy, as it encourages lawmakers to look beyond political divides when considering healthcare reforms. The index highlights specific policy areas, such as granting prescriptive authority to psychologists or reforming certificate-of-need laws, which could improve patient access and reduce barriers to care across various states. This non-partisan approach could foster more collaborative legislative efforts, potentially leading to more patient-centered and efficient healthcare systems nationwide, benefiting citizens regardless of their state's political leanings.
What's Next?
The Center for Modern Health aims for lawmakers to utilize the 2026 Health Freedom Index as a tool for identifying and implementing policy improvements. Following the midterms, the detailed policy-level scores can guide legislative discussions on non-partisan issues. For instance, states currently without prescriptive authority for psychologists might consider adopting such measures, potentially expanding mental health access. Similarly, states with restrictive certificate-of-need laws could re-evaluate these regulations to foster greater competition and innovation in healthcare delivery. The 'Right to Try' laws, which allow patients access to investigational treatments, are also highlighted as an area where states across the political spectrum could improve. The index's companion analysis of red, blue, and purple states, available online, provides further data for policymakers to explore and potentially integrate into future legislative agendas, encouraging a more unified approach to health policy reform.
Beyond the Headlines
The Health Freedom Index's findings suggest a deeper narrative about the evolving landscape of healthcare policy in the U.S., moving beyond simplistic partisan labels. The fact that states like Arizona and Colorado, with differing political leanings, can both achieve high rankings indicates that practical, patient-focused policies can transcend ideological divides. This could signal a shift towards a more pragmatic approach in healthcare governance, where the efficacy and accessibility of care take precedence over political posturing. The index implicitly encourages a re-evaluation of what constitutes 'health freedom,' broadening the definition beyond traditional debates to include aspects like professional autonomy for healthcare providers and patient access to diverse treatment options. This could foster a more nuanced public discourse on healthcare, emphasizing shared goals rather than entrenched political positions, and potentially leading to more resilient and adaptable healthcare systems in the long term.













