What's Happening?
Kali Watson, Director of the State Department of Hawaiian Home Lands (DHHL), announced his resignation effective December 31, after a nearly four-year term. Watson led the agency in advancing a pipeline of almost 30 homestead subdivision projects, utilizing
$600 million appropriated by the Legislature in 2022, and issuing several thousand house lot leases. Despite these efforts, the vast majority of these lots are not yet created for beneficiaries to occupy. Watson stated that 5,305 homestead leases were offered during Governor Green's first term, a record number, with plans to offer nearly 4,900 more leases next year. However, many of these are 'undivided land interest leases' or 'paper leases,' meaning the physical lots are not yet available. Governor Josh Green praised Watson's work in addressing the long waitlist for Native Hawaiian homelands. This marks Watson's second tenure as DHHL Director, having previously served from 1995 to 1998.
Why It's Important?
The departure of Director Watson at a critical juncture highlights the ongoing challenges in fulfilling the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act's promise to return ancestral lands to Native Hawaiians. While a record number of leases have been issued, the fact that most are 'paper leases' means beneficiaries still await physical land. This situation underscores the significant gap between policy and tangible outcomes, impacting thousands of Native Hawaiian families who have been on a waitlist for generations. The reliance on future legislative funding for lot development suggests that progress is vulnerable to political and economic fluctuations. The ability to transfer these 'paper leases' to eligible relatives offers a partial solution for beneficiaries who might otherwise die before receiving land, but it does not address the fundamental issue of land availability. The continuity of leadership and funding will be crucial for the DHHL to convert these leases into actual homes and address the substantial waitlist of approximately 30,000 beneficiaries.
What's Next?
Following Director Watson's departure, Governor Green will need to appoint a new leader for the DHHL. The incoming director will face the immediate challenge of securing additional funding from the state legislature to develop the approximately 6,000 lots associated with the 30 projects currently in the pipeline. The agency intends to offer nearly 4,900 more leases next year, bringing the total to over 10,000 leases in five years, further increasing the pressure to develop physical homesteads. Watson plans to return to his previous role running the Hawaiian Community Development Board, a nonprofit focused on affordable housing and commercial project development, where he may continue to explore opportunities with the Office of Hawaiian Affairs (OHA) and other organizations to benefit Hawaiians. The focus will remain on how quickly the DHHL can transition from issuing 'paper leases' to providing tangible land and housing for Native Hawaiian families.
Beyond the Headlines
The persistent issue of the Native Hawaiian homestead waitlist, spanning over a century since the Hawaiian Homes Commission Act was created in 1921, reveals deeper systemic challenges in land distribution and indigenous rights. The practice of issuing 'undivided land interest leases' or 'paper leases' highlights a complex administrative strategy to acknowledge beneficiaries while grappling with resource limitations. While these leases offer a mechanism for intergenerational transfer, they also defer the promise of actual land ownership, potentially creating a sense of prolonged anticipation and frustration among beneficiaries. The situation underscores the ethical and historical obligations of the U.S. government and the state of Hawaii to address the land claims of Native Hawaiians. The ongoing struggle for land access reflects broader themes of historical injustice, land sovereignty, and the economic disparities faced by indigenous populations, making the DHHL's progress a critical indicator of commitment to these issues.













