What's Happening?
Aurora Water officials are actively working to provide additional water quality information requested by the state for a Regulation 87 dredge and fill permit. This permit is crucial for the proposed Wild Horse Reservoir in Park County, which intends to partially
draw water from Homestake Creek in Eagle County. The Colorado Department of Public Health and Environment (CDPHE) has set a deadline of Thursday, November 19, for public comments on the project. While the current comment period will not be extended, CDPHE plans to open another public notice and comment period once Aurora Water submits the requested water quality data and analyses. Local water officials, including those from the Eagle River Water and Sanitation District and Upper Eagle Regional Water Authority, are increasingly opposing the proposal, citing concerns about existing transmountain diversions and the ongoing drought conditions. They argue that Homestake Creek and the Upper Eagle River are already significantly impacted by current water diversions to the Front Range.
Why It's Important?
This development is significant for water management and environmental policy in Colorado. The proposed Wild Horse Reservoir highlights the ongoing tension between urban water demands and the environmental impact on source regions, particularly in the context of a severe drought. If approved, the project would allow Aurora Water to expand its water storage capacity, potentially securing future water supplies for its growing population. However, opponents argue that further diversions from the Western Slope could exacerbate ecological stress on the Homestake Creek and Upper Eagle River basins, which already experience substantial water removal. The outcome of this permit application could set a precedent for future water infrastructure projects in Colorado, influencing how water rights are exercised and how environmental concerns are balanced against municipal needs. The debate also underscores the broader challenges of water scarcity and resource allocation in the American West.
What's Next?
The immediate next step involves Aurora Water submitting the additional water quality information to the CDPHE before the November 19 deadline. Following this submission, the CDPHE will initiate another public notice and comment period specifically for the new water quality data and analyses. Stakeholders, including local water authorities and environmental groups, are expected to continue voicing their concerns and submitting comments during this subsequent period. The CDPHE's decision on the Regulation 87 permit will be a critical juncture for the Wild Horse Reservoir project. Depending on the state's ruling, Aurora Water may proceed with its plans, or it could face further regulatory hurdles or legal challenges from opposing entities. The ongoing drought conditions and increasing scrutiny on water resource management suggest that this project will remain a focal point of environmental and political debate in Colorado.
Beyond the Headlines
The controversy surrounding the Wild Horse Reservoir project extends beyond immediate water supply issues, touching upon deeper ethical and legal dimensions of water rights in the Western U.S. The debate over 'transmountain diversions' highlights a long-standing conflict between the water-rich Western Slope and the more populous Front Range. This project forces a re-evaluation of historical water allocation doctrines in the face of climate change, which is altering snowpack and runoff patterns. Critics argue that Aurora Water's modeling and analyses may not adequately account for these rapidly changing hydrologic conditions, suggesting a need for updated environmental assessments that reflect current and foreseeable climate impacts. The outcome could influence how future water projects are evaluated, potentially leading to more stringent requirements for climate impact assessments and a greater emphasis on basin-of-origin protection. This case also underscores the growing importance of inter-county cooperation and conflict resolution in managing shared natural resources.













