What's Happening?
The Montana Department of Environmental Quality (DEQ) is employing risk-based screening levels (RBSLs) for soil and groundwater to manage petroleum contamination at release sites. While DEQ-7, a state standard, lists only about a dozen chemicals found
in petroleum products, these products contain hundreds of chemicals. To address this, DEQ developed the Montana Tier 1 Risk Based Corrective Action Guidance for Petroleum Releases (RBCA) document. This guidance defines RBSLs, which are concentrations of petroleum chemicals used to evaluate risks to human health and the environment. Petroleum releases cleaned up to levels below these RBSLs are considered protective. The RBCA document has been incorporated by reference into Montana tank rules concerning site closure, specifically ARM 17.56.608. This approach allows for the closure of sites where petroleum chemicals not listed in DEQ-7 are present, provided they meet the established RBSLs.
Why It's Important?
This approach by the Montana DEQ is significant for environmental protection and public health within the state. By using RBSLs, the DEQ can address a broader range of petroleum contaminants beyond the limited scope of DEQ-7, ensuring a more comprehensive cleanup process. This is crucial because petroleum products contain numerous chemicals, many of which pose risks to human health through direct contact, inhalation, ingestion of contaminated water, or vapor migration into buildings. The implementation of RBSLs provides a standardized method for evaluating these risks and determining appropriate cleanup levels, which can lead to more effective remediation of contaminated sites. This benefits communities by reducing exposure to harmful substances and protecting groundwater resources, which are vital for drinking water. Furthermore, it offers a clear framework for site owners and operators, facilitating the closure of petroleum release sites once protective levels are achieved.
What's Next?
The Montana DEQ will continue to utilize and periodically update its RBCA guidance document to ensure that the RBSLs remain current and protective of human health and the environment. Site owners and operators of petroleum release sites in Montana will need to adhere to these RBSLs for cleanup and closure. The DEQ also considers other methods for risk evaluation, indicating a flexible approach to site-specific conditions. For sites where groundwater contamination exceeds DEQ-7 standards or RBSLs, but is not migrating beyond property boundaries, a petroleum mixing zone closure may be granted. This requires the owner/operator to demonstrate that cleanup has reached the maximum extent practicable, the plume is decreasing, and there is no other risk to receptors, allowing for closure even with residual groundwater contamination under specific conditions.
Beyond the Headlines
The use of risk-based screening levels by the Montana DEQ highlights a broader trend in environmental regulation towards more nuanced and scientifically informed approaches to contamination cleanup. Instead of relying solely on fixed, often limited, lists of contaminants, this method allows for a more dynamic assessment of risk based on the specific chemical composition of pollutants and their potential pathways to human exposure and environmental harm. This can lead to more efficient allocation of resources, focusing on the most significant risks. However, it also places a greater responsibility on regulatory bodies to ensure that the RBSLs are robust, regularly updated with the latest scientific understanding, and transparently applied. The concept of a 'petroleum mixing zone closure' also raises questions about the long-term management of residual contamination and the balance between practical cleanup limits and absolute environmental purity, which are ongoing challenges in environmental policy.













