What's Happening?
Hawaii's tourism industry is facing a significant challenge due to a sharp decline in visitor survey participation after the state transitioned from paper agricultural declaration forms to the digital Akamai Arrival system. This digital shift, which began
on March 1, 2025, initially removed tourism questions from the mandatory agricultural declaration. Although these questions were later restored, the response rate for the tourism section has plummeted. Jennifer Chun, director of tourism research at the Department of Business, Economic Development and Tourism (DBEDT), stated that while 70% of travelers completed the tourism survey with paper forms, only 23% now complete the separate digital tourism survey. This has led to a decrease in daily survey responses from approximately 11,000 paper forms to about 1,400 fully completed digital submissions. As a direct consequence, DBEDT has ceased publishing visitor figures for Molokai and Lanai due to unreliable estimates, raising concerns among industry leaders about the accuracy of detailed visitor characteristics and behavior data.
Why It's Important?
The loss of critical visitor data has profound implications for Hawaii's tourism industry, which relies heavily on this information for strategic planning and marketing. Tourism agencies, policymakers, and businesses use this data to guide marketing investments, track trends, and make informed decisions about future developments. According to Keith Vieira, principal of KV & Associates Hospitality Consulting, this data was a 'competitive advantage' for Hawaii. Jerry Gibson, president of the Hawai'i Hotel Alliance, highlighted that incomplete data can lead to poor decisions regarding hotel renovations, product development, staffing, amenities, and future tourism investments. The lack of reliable data particularly impacts smaller islands like Molokai and Lanai, where specific visitor insights are crucial for community-driven destination management plans. Economist Paul Brewbaker described the disruption as a 'permanent gap year in economic time series continuity,' emphasizing the long-term consequences of this data void on understanding visitor behavior and market shifts.
What's Next?
State agencies are actively exploring solutions to increase tourism survey participation and improve data collection. Jennifer Chun indicated that efforts are underway to enhance the technology linking Akamai Arrival and the tourism survey, address data-sharing challenges, and provide researchers with more usable visitor data. State Sen. Glenn Wakai, while acknowledging concerns, believes the current 23% digital response rate is still statistically meaningful but aims for higher participation. He proposes 'gamifying' the survey by offering incentives such as coupons, discounts, or promotions from local businesses to encourage completion. Both Wakai and Keith Vieira oppose making participation mandatory, fearing it could damage goodwill and result in poor-quality responses. Jerry Gibson suggested an alternative approach: collecting information directly from industry sources like airlines and hotels, similar to how STR hotel-performance reports are compiled, or hiring a professional firm to aggregate such data.
Beyond the Headlines
The shift to digital systems, while often aimed at modernization and efficiency, can inadvertently create unforeseen challenges, as seen in Hawaii's tourism data dilemma. This situation highlights the delicate balance between technological advancement and the preservation of essential data streams. The debate over mandatory versus incentivized survey participation touches upon broader ethical considerations regarding data collection and visitor experience. Forcing participation could lead to resentment and inaccurate responses, while incentives could transform data collection into a marketing opportunity. The reliance on direct visitor surveys versus aggregated industry data also raises questions about data ownership, privacy, and the comprehensiveness of insights. This development could prompt other states or regions considering similar digital transitions to implement parallel systems or more robust consultation processes to avoid similar 'permanent gap years' in critical economic data.













