What's Happening?
A recent World Bank report, 'Digital Public Infrastructure for Inclusive Growth: A Regional Assessment for the Middle East, North Africa, Afghanistan, and Pakistan (MENAAP),' reveals significant gaps in digital ID integration across the region. While
all 21 MENAAP countries possess foundational ID systems, only 10 have full digital ID capabilities for secure remote authentication. The report, based on research from August 2025 to February 2026, indicates that only five countries—Jordan, Oman, Saudi Arabia, Tunisia, and the UAE—offer a complete range of integrated transactional services. This fragmentation limits the potential for economic growth and efficient delivery of public and private sector services. For instance, Jordan's Sanad platform provides remote digital ID capabilities, yet only 19% of adults hold an online digital ID, with a notable gender gap (23% men vs. 15% women). Similarly, Morocco has nearly universal foundational ID coverage, but digital ID adoption remains below 25% of adults. The report emphasizes that the value of digital ID systems is maximized when integrated with payments, data sharing, and other services, rather than operating as standalone components.
Why It's Important?
The findings underscore a critical challenge for economic development and digital transformation in the MENAAP region. The lack of integrated digital public infrastructure (DPI) means that even with foundational ID systems, countries are unable to fully leverage digital tools to improve service delivery and foster inclusive growth. This 'integration deficit' particularly affects middle-income nations like Jordan, Morocco, Egypt, Tunisia, and Pakistan, leading to difficulties in accessing digital services, weak data protection enforcement, and a lack of operational Certificate Authorities for e-signature legislation. For low-income and conflict-affected states such as Afghanistan, Syria, Yemen, Lebanon, and Libya, basic digital ID capabilities and data-sharing platforms are largely absent. Addressing these gaps is crucial for these economies to participate effectively in the global digital economy, enhance governance, and provide essential services more efficiently to their populations. The report also highlights a global issue, noting that approximately 800 million people worldwide lack official identification, and 2.8 billion lack access to a government-recognized digital ID for secure online transactions, indicating that the MENAAP region's challenges are part of a broader international problem.
What's Next?
The World Bank report recommends several key actions to address the digital ID integration gaps. Countries need to complete their digital public infrastructure stack by integrating existing components. This includes transforming government service portals into one-stop shops with single sign-on, automated data consent, integrated payments, and back-end registry interoperability. Strengthening whole-of-government coordination and data governance for DPI systems is also crucial, alongside making e-signatures operational and designing systems with gender equality and fragile contexts in mind. For fragile countries, the recommendation is to build durable foundations, including basic legal frameworks, civil registries, and portable, offline-capable digital ID and payment tools that are resilient to institutional disruption and low connectivity. The World Bank's grant to Jordan to expand its Sanad platform to businesses and integrate AI-powered features exemplifies the type of investment needed to move forward. These steps aim to enhance the practical value of digital identities in the digital environment, moving beyond mere foundational ID systems to comprehensive, integrated digital ecosystems.
Beyond the Headlines
The 'digital paradox' identified by the World Bank—where increased connectivity and digital infrastructure don't translate to productive use due to fragmentation—reveals deeper systemic issues. Beyond the immediate economic impact, the lack of integrated digital IDs can perpetuate social inequalities, particularly for women, as seen in Jordan's gender gap in digital ID adoption. It also raises questions about data privacy and security in fragmented systems, where inconsistent enforcement of data protection laws can leave citizens vulnerable. The reliance on a few advanced nations for digital ID capabilities also highlights a potential digital divide within the region, where wealthier nations maintain sophisticated systems while others struggle with basic infrastructure. The long-term implications include hindered innovation, reduced foreign investment, and a slower pace of modernization, potentially widening the gap between the MENAAP region and more digitally advanced economies. The report implicitly calls for a more holistic approach to digital transformation, one that prioritizes interoperability, inclusivity, and robust governance frameworks to ensure that digital advancements benefit all segments of society.













