What's Happening?
Following the recent midterm elections, states are increasingly opting to decouple from federal tax breaks rather than raising income tax rates, according to tax professionals Greg Rottjakob and Samuel
Tae. This trend is particularly evident in Democratic-leaning states, which are more inclined to adopt base-broadening federal changes while rejecting deductions like bonus depreciation. Greg Rottjakob, principal and national leader of Ryan’s State Income and Franchise Tax practice, noted that states are expected to take an extended period to respond to the One Big Beautiful Bill (OBBB), P.L. 119-21, similar to their reaction to the Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA), P.L. 115-97. The OBBB made 100% bonus depreciation under IRC § 168(k) permanent and allowed immediate expensing of domestic research or experimental expenditures under new IRC § 174A. Decoupling generally stretches these deductions over a longer period for state purposes. States are decoupling because the OBBB shifted more of the cost burden to them, particularly with the federal share of Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program administrative costs falling to 25% from 50% starting in fiscal year 2027.
Why It's Important?
This strategic shift by states has significant implications for businesses and taxpayers across the U.S. By decoupling from federal tax breaks, states can generate additional revenue without directly increasing income tax rates, which is often a politically sensitive move. This approach allows states to maintain funding for essential programs, such as those previously supported by federal contributions, while potentially making their tax systems appear more stable to voters. For businesses, particularly those operating across multiple states, this creates a complex tax environment. Multinationals with U.S. assets may find themselves in a more favorable position under new foreign income rules, while those heavily invested abroad could face disadvantages. The differing state responses to federal tax legislation necessitate careful tax planning and compliance strategies for companies to navigate varying deduction schedules and tax bases. The decision to decouple also highlights the ongoing tension between federal tax policy objectives and state-level fiscal needs.
What's Next?
States are likely to continue evaluating and adjusting their tax codes in response to federal legislation like the OBBB. With new state governments, particularly in states where Democrats gained control, there could be further moves to decouple from federal provisions that would raise state revenue. Businesses should anticipate a prolonged period of state-level tax adjustments and should monitor legislative developments closely. The focus on decoupling rather than direct rate increases suggests that states will seek alternative methods to bolster their budgets, potentially through other tax mechanisms like sales or property taxes. For multinational corporations, understanding the nuances of new foreign income rules, such as the renamed global intangible low-taxed income (GILTI) to net CFC tested income (NCTI), will be crucial for optimizing their tax positions. The safe harbor provision under Pillar Two, which recognizes robust U.S. tax systems, may also influence how U.S. multinationals are treated internationally.
Beyond the Headlines
The trend of states decoupling from federal tax breaks reflects a deeper political and economic dynamic in the U.S. It underscores the fiscal pressures states face and their creative approaches to revenue generation in a post-midterm election landscape. This strategy allows state leaders to address budgetary needs while avoiding the political fallout often associated with direct tax hikes. However, it also contributes to a more fragmented and complex tax system for businesses, potentially increasing compliance costs and administrative burdens. The differing approaches between Democratic and Republican-leaning states could lead to significant variations in tax liabilities for companies depending on their operational footprint. This divergence also highlights the ongoing debate about federalism and the balance of power between federal and state governments in shaping economic policy, particularly in areas like taxation and fiscal responsibility.








