What's Happening?
The U.S. military and its allies face persistent challenges in effectively countering insurgent networks, as evidenced by past operations in Afghanistan and ongoing efforts against groups like the Islamic State. A key issue identified is 'replacement
bias,' where intelligence efforts focus on replacing a disrupted element rather than understanding how the adversary continues to perform essential functions. For instance, during the 2009–2010 deployment in Afghanistan, targeting lower-level insurgent leaders proved ineffective as they were quickly replaced. Similarly, the killing of Islamic State leader Abu Muhammad al-Adnani in 2016 resulted in only a temporary setback, as responsibilities were structured to pass down the hierarchy. The Islamic State's adaptation after losing territorial control in 2019 further illustrates this, as the group shifted to insurgency tactics for managing networks and funding, demonstrating that losing territory did not eliminate the need for financing. This highlights the need for a 'Function-First Analysis' (FFA) approach, which focuses on the operational requirements that remain after an intervention, rather than just the disrupted form.
Why It's Important?
This analytical challenge has significant implications for U.S. national security and military effectiveness in combating global insurgencies. A failure to understand how insurgent networks adapt and continue to operate after interventions can lead to prolonged conflicts and inefficient resource allocation. If the U.S. military continues to focus on 'replacement bias,' it risks underestimating the resilience of adversaries and failing to disrupt their core capabilities. The ability of groups like the Islamic State to transition from territorial control to insurgency tactics demonstrates their adaptability and the need for more sophisticated counter-insurgency strategies. This impacts not only military operations but also intelligence gathering, as successful interventions can alter the intelligence environment, potentially reducing visibility into adversary activities. A more effective approach, like FFA, could lead to more targeted and sustainable interventions, ultimately enhancing U.S. security interests by more effectively dismantling insurgent capabilities.
What's Next?
Moving forward, the U.S. intelligence community and military strategists are encouraged to adopt a Function-First Analysis (FFA) approach. This involves shifting focus from merely identifying what replaces a disrupted element to understanding how adversaries continue to perform critical functions. This analytical shift requires planning for the adversary's 'second move' by considering how they might realistically respond to an intervention and identifying early indicators of such responses. Intelligence agencies will need to track functions rather than just forms, assess what the adversary's response requires in terms of resources and relationships, and treat observed responses as evidence to revise their understanding of the adversary's capabilities. This proactive and adaptive approach aims to create more effective and sustainable counter-insurgency strategies, potentially leading to better long-term outcomes in conflicts against resilient non-state actors.
Beyond the Headlines
The shift towards Function-First Analysis (FFA) represents a deeper evolution in strategic thinking beyond traditional counter-insurgency tactics. It acknowledges the inherent adaptability of complex networks and the limitations of purely kinetic or leadership-focused interventions. This approach has ethical implications, as it encourages a more holistic understanding of an adversary's operational ecosystem, potentially leading to more precise and less collateral-damaging interventions. Legally, understanding the functional resilience of insurgent groups can inform policy debates on the scope and duration of military engagements, as well as the legal frameworks for intelligence collection and targeting. Culturally, it signifies a move away from a 'whack-a-mole' approach to a more nuanced, systems-thinking perspective, recognizing that underlying grievances and operational needs often drive insurgent behavior more than individual leaders or specific tools. This long-term shift could foster more sustainable security strategies and a more effective response to evolving global threats.













