What's Happening?
In a recent address at the 92NY in Manhattan, New York Times columnist Bret Stephens argued that the American Jewish community should shift its focus from combating antisemitism to strengthening Jewish identity. Stephens suggested dismantling organizations
like the Anti-Defamation League, which he believes consume significant resources in a 'mostly wasted effort' against antisemitism. He emphasized that the funds and energy currently directed towards fighting antisemitism and pro-Israel advocacy could be better spent on initiatives that build Jewish identity, such as establishing more Jewish day schools. Stephens' remarks come at a time when Jewish communities in the U.S. are reassessing their priorities following the release of hostages and a ceasefire in the Israel-Hamas conflict.
Why It's Important?
Stephens' proposal highlights a significant debate within the American Jewish community about the best use of its resources. By advocating for a focus on Jewish identity rather than antisemitism, Stephens is challenging long-standing strategies and suggesting a shift in priorities that could impact funding and policy decisions. This debate is crucial as it could redefine how Jewish organizations allocate their resources and address community needs. The potential redirection of funds towards education and identity-building could strengthen cultural ties and community resilience, but it also raises questions about the ongoing fight against antisemitism and how it will be managed without the current level of funding.
What's Next?
If Stephens' suggestions gain traction, Jewish organizations may begin to reevaluate their funding strategies and program priorities. This could lead to increased investment in educational initiatives and community-building activities. However, it may also prompt discussions about how to continue addressing antisemitism effectively with potentially reduced resources. Stakeholders, including Jewish leaders and philanthropists, will likely engage in debates about the balance between identity-building and combating antisemitism, potentially leading to new strategies and collaborations.
