What's Happening?
On September 18, 2026, the Department of Justice (DOJ) announced significant revisions to its Justice Manual concerning two key areas: the dismissal of False Claims Act (FCA) qui tam suits and the issuance and use of agency guidance documents in litigation.
The changes to the qui tam dismissal process now require DOJ attorneys to consider dismissing a complaint before declining to intervene, and they broaden the grounds for dismissal beyond facially meritless cases to those that more broadly lack merit. Regarding agency guidance, the DOJ has reinstated limitations on its use, aligning with policies from the first Trump administration. This means sub-regulatory guidance cannot impose legal obligations beyond statutes or regulations and cannot be the sole basis for proving violations in affirmative civil enforcement cases.
Why It's Important?
These revisions have substantial implications for whistleblowers, defendants in FCA cases, and federal agencies. For defendants, the expanded grounds for dismissal and the requirement for DOJ attorneys to consider dismissal earlier could lead to more qui tam cases being dismissed, potentially reducing litigation exposure. Whistleblowers, or relators, may face a higher bar for their cases to proceed if the DOJ determines they lack sufficient merit, even if not frivolous. The changes regarding agency guidance aim to prevent agencies from creating de facto regulations through guidance documents, which could impact how federal agencies enforce laws and how regulated entities interpret compliance requirements. This shift emphasizes that legal obligations must stem from statutes or formal regulations, not informal guidance.
What's Next?
DOJ attorneys are now mandated to assess dismissal in every qui tam case before declining to intervene, meaning declination recommendations will also need to address dismissal. This change gives defendants greater incentive to press the DOJ for dismissal before an intervention decision is made. While sub-regulatory guidance cannot establish liability on its own, it remains admissible to demonstrate scienter, notice, industry standards, and relevant context in FCA litigation. Therefore, nonbinding guidance will continue to play a significant role in proving elements like knowledge or intent. The DOJ's stated commitment to dismissing meritless cases, combined with these new guidelines, suggests a more proactive approach to managing qui tam litigation.
Beyond the Headlines
The DOJ's policy shift reflects a broader debate about the balance of power between administrative agencies and the judiciary, particularly concerning the legal weight of agency guidance. By limiting the use of sub-regulatory guidance, the DOJ is reinforcing the principle that only duly enacted statutes and regulations carry the force of law, potentially curbing what some view as regulatory overreach. This could lead to more clarity for regulated industries but might also make it harder for agencies to adapt quickly to emerging issues without formal rulemaking. The changes also highlight a continued effort to refine the False Claims Act's enforcement mechanisms, aiming to prevent the government from being burdened by cases it deems lacking in merit, while still encouraging legitimate whistleblowing.













