What's Happening?
A recent survey conducted by YouGov, commissioned by Airbnb, indicates that imposing further booking limits on short-stay properties in Australia would have minimal impact on increasing rental supply and affordability in major cities. The survey, which polled over 1000 Airbnb hosts in Sydney and Melbourne, found that only about one in eight hosts would consider transitioning their property to long-term rental if caps were imposed. Currently, more than 47,500 dwellings in New South Wales are registered as short-term rentals, with over 30,000 being 'non-hosted,' meaning the owner does not reside there. In Victoria, a 7.5% levy on short-term rental accommodation was introduced in January. Despite these measures, many hosts indicated their properties were unsuitable for long-term rental or were second homes, and would likely remain empty if further caps were enforced.
AD
Why It's Important?
The findings highlight the challenges in addressing housing affordability through restrictions on short-term rentals. Airbnb's public policy head, Michael Crosby, argues that such measures do not effectively increase housing availability and may harm individuals relying on short-term rentals for additional income. The survey results suggest that short-term rentals constitute a small portion of the overall housing stock, and harsh restrictions could lead to properties remaining vacant rather than being converted to long-term rentals. This underscores the complexity of balancing tourism-driven short-term rental markets with housing needs, and the potential ineffectiveness of caps in solving broader housing issues.
What's Next?
The survey results may prompt policymakers to reconsider the effectiveness of caps and levies on short-term rentals as a strategy for improving housing affordability. Urban planning experts, like Nicole Gurran from the University of Sydney, recommend that governments establish programs to facilitate the transition of properties to long-term rentals, particularly those well-located relative to housing needs. This could involve creating incentives or support systems for property owners to make their homes suitable for long-term rental markets, potentially addressing the barriers identified in the survey.
Beyond the Headlines
The resistance to caps on short-term rentals reflects broader economic and social dynamics, including the reliance on tourism and the financial pressures faced by property owners. The debate over short-term rental regulations also touches on ethical considerations regarding housing accessibility and the rights of homeowners to utilize their properties as they see fit. Long-term shifts in housing policy may be necessary to address these complex issues, balancing economic benefits with social equity.
